Thompson B, Bowen D J, Croyle R T, Hopp H P, Fries E
School of Public Health and Community Medicine, University of Washington, Seattle.
Am J Health Promot. 1991 Nov-Dec;6(2):130-7. doi: 10.4278/0890-1171-6.2.130.
Worksites are natural settings for health promotion. In many cases, the effectiveness of such interventions is appraised by surveying employees to assess worksite-wide changes in the targeted behavior. Little attention has been paid to increasing worksite survey response rates. One way is to utilize community organization strategies, which involve enlisting the individuals within a group to work together with researchers to affect the social environment.
Community organization strategies and multiple contacts were used to obtain responses from employees in five worksites involved in a smoking cessation project. Employee Advisory Board members in each worksite reviewed, adapted, and revised the survey distribution method, the messages that accompanied the survey, and the survey content. Three major survey waves were undertaken: a worksite effort, a home mailing (in the pilot worksite only), and a telephone call to nonrespondents.
Response rates to a worksite-wide survey in one worksite the first year and four additional worksites the next year yielded 99.3% and 98.4% response rates, respectively. In the pilot worksite, 273 employees were eligible for the survey with 366 eligible employees in the four other worksites. Chi-square or analysis of variance computations were used, as appropriate, to test for differences in characteristics of respondents in the various data collection waves.
These results suggest that there may be merit in adapting such community organization intervention methods for research applications.
工作场所是促进健康的自然场所。在许多情况下,此类干预措施的有效性是通过对员工进行调查来评估目标行为在整个工作场所的变化。很少有人关注提高工作场所调查的回应率。一种方法是利用社区组织策略,即让一个群体中的个体与研究人员合作,共同影响社会环境。
采用社区组织策略和多次联系,从参与戒烟项目的五个工作场所的员工那里获取回应。每个工作场所的员工咨询委员会成员审查、调整并修订了调查问卷的分发方式、随附的信息以及调查内容。进行了三轮主要调查:一次工作场所调查、一次家庭邮寄(仅在试点工作场所)以及对未回应者的电话访问。
第一年,一个工作场所的全场所调查回应率为99.3%,次年另外四个工作场所的回应率为98.4%。在试点工作场所,有273名员工符合调查条件,其他四个工作场所则有366名符合条件的员工。根据情况,使用卡方检验或方差分析计算来检验不同数据收集轮次中受访者特征的差异。
这些结果表明,将此类社区组织干预方法应用于研究可能有其价值。