Belaiche J, Van Kemseke C, Louis E
Dept. of Gastroenterology, Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Sart Tilman, University of Liège, Belgium.
Endoscopy. 1999 May;31(4):298-301. doi: 10.1055/s-1999-17.
The small intestine is a potential origin of bleeding in patients with unexplained gastrointestinal tract hemorrhage or iron-deficiency anemia. Most reports on the investigation of these patients describe the use of upper tract enteroscopy. The diagnostic yield of combined upper and lower enteroscopy has not been widely assessed and remains to be clarified. The aim of this study was to assess the benefit of lower gastrointestinal tract enteroscopy in occult digestive bleeding.
Between 1 December 1995 and 15 January 1998, 54 patients with gastrointestinal bleeding of unknown origin were prospectively studied using upper and lower video push enteroscopy (44 for chronic iron-deficiency anemia and 10 for unexplained gastrointestinal tract hemorrhage with no potential site having been identified by other investigations). Examinations were done using a Olympus video enteroscope (SIF-100) under general anesthesia in a one-day clinic. An upper tract examination was done first, directly followed by the lower tract investigation.
The upper tract enteroscopy was successful in 53 patients (98%) and retrograde ileoscopy in 21 patients (39%). In 18 (38%) cases the technical failure resulted from the impossibility of intubating the ileocecal valve. A potential source of upper gastrointestinal bleeding was detected in 35% of patients with chronic iron-deficiency anemia and in 20% of those with unexplained gastrointestinal tract hemorrhage. The most common lesion in the small bowel was angiodysplasia (25%). The lower tract video push enteroscopy disclosed 11 lesions in patients with chronic anemia. However the lesions, including two ileocecal valve cancers, were mainly located in the colon and had been missed by previous colonoscopy. No case of ileal lesion was detected in this group of patients. In patients with unexplained gastrointestinal tract hemorrhage, three lesions were detected but only one of these was in the ileum. Associated colonic and jejunal lesions were observed in three patients (5.5%). Overall, the diagnostic yield of lower video push enteroscopy was less than 2%.
This prospective study has shown that using an enteroscope as a colonoscope in the management of patients with gastrointestinal bleeding of unknown origin is of little help. It might actually be more appropriate to perform a second colonoscopy. This however remains controversial and a prospective study is needed to answer that question.
小肠是不明原因胃肠道出血或缺铁性贫血患者出血的潜在来源。关于这些患者检查的大多数报告描述了上消化道小肠镜检查的应用。上下消化道联合小肠镜检查的诊断率尚未得到广泛评估,仍有待明确。本研究的目的是评估下消化道小肠镜检查在隐匿性消化性出血中的益处。
在1995年12月1日至1998年1月15日期间,对54例不明原因胃肠道出血患者进行了前瞻性研究,采用上下消化道视频推进式小肠镜检查(44例为慢性缺铁性贫血患者,10例为不明原因胃肠道出血患者,其他检查未发现潜在出血部位)。检查在一日门诊全身麻醉下使用奥林巴斯视频小肠镜(SIF - 100)进行。先进行上消化道检查,紧接着进行下消化道检查。
上消化道小肠镜检查53例成功(98%),逆行回肠镜检查21例成功(39%)。18例(38%)技术失败是由于无法插入回盲瓣。在35%的慢性缺铁性贫血患者和20%的不明原因胃肠道出血患者中检测到上消化道出血的潜在来源。小肠最常见的病变是血管发育异常(25%)。下消化道视频推进式小肠镜检查在慢性贫血患者中发现了11处病变。然而,这些病变,包括2例回盲瓣癌,主要位于结肠,之前的结肠镜检查未能发现。在这组患者中未检测到一例回肠病变。在不明原因胃肠道出血患者中,发现了3处病变,但其中只有一处在回肠。3例患者(5.5%)观察到合并的结肠和空肠病变。总体而言,下消化道视频推进式小肠镜检查的诊断率低于2%。
这项前瞻性研究表明,在不明原因胃肠道出血患者的管理中,将小肠镜用作结肠镜帮助不大。实际上,进行第二次结肠镜检查可能更合适。然而,这仍存在争议,需要进行前瞻性研究来回答这个问题。