Do interventional radiologists pose a significant threat to the practice of vascular surgery?

PURPOSE

Vascular surgeons have become concerned recently about perceived threats to their practices posed by the growth of interventional radiology. The authors studied nationwide 1996 Medicare Part B procedure data to determine the seriousness of these threats.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The national Health Care Financing Administration (HCFA) Physician/Supplier Procedure Summary Master File for 1996 was searched. Two hundred thirteen distinct Current Procedural Terminology (CPT-4) codes were identified for therapeutic surgical and percutaneous interventional procedures performed to treat noncardiac vascular diseases. For each code, determination was made of total volume, specialty of the physician providers, and Medicare Part B reimbursement dollars paid to the providers as professional fees. In view of the conflicts among various specialties over peripheral vascular interventions, the authors also determined the percentages of these procedures performed by radiologists, surgeons, cardiologists, and other physicians.

RESULTS

A total of 759,548 noncardiac therapeutic vascular procedures (operations or percutaneous interventions) were performed during 1996 in patients receiving Medicare benefits. Radiologists performed 135,103 (17.8%) of these procedures but received only 10.4% of professional reimbursements. By contrast, surgeons performed 510,871 (67.3%) procedures, but received 78.0% of professional reimbursements. Cardiologists performed 4.7% of procedures and other specialists performed the remaining 10.3%. Radiologists performed 75.5% of percutaneous transluminal angioplasties, the majority of thrombolysis procedures, stent placements, and portal decompression procedures, and approximately half of inferior vena cava interruptions. Cardiologists performed 12.6% of percutaneous transluminal angioplasties, surgeons performed 6.3%, and other specialists performed 5.6%.

CONCLUSIONS

In terms of overall physician workload and professional reimbursements paid for invasive treatment of all types of noncardiac vascular disease, surgeons predominate and do not appear to be seriously threatened by interventional radiologists. Radiologists perform three-fourths of noncardiac percutaneous transluminal angioplasties and a majority of other percutaneous interventional therapies for vascular disease, but some inroads have been made by cardiologists and surgeons, particularly the former.