Rosin A, Sinopoli M
Department of Emergency Medicine, 121st General Hospital, Seoul, South Korea.
Mil Med. 1999 Nov;164(11):793-4.
The impact of the Ottawa Ankle Rules on radiograph-ordering behavior was assessed. Medical records and radiology reports for 80 consecutive patients who presented with the complaint of acute ankle pain were retrospectively reviewed for 18 variables. Twenty-two patients met the rules criteria and 45 did not. There were 10 fractures in the study group (N = 67), 3 of which were missed by the rules. All 3 fractures were 1-mm avulsion fractures of the fibula and are considered not clinically significant. Application of the Ottawa Ankle Rules by all clinic providers would have decreased the number of radiographs at our facility by 68%. The rules had sensitivity and specificity of 70% and 73%, and positive and negative predictive values of 31.8% and 93.3%, respectively. Providers at our facility did not routinely use the rules. Although the incorporation of these rules into our practice would have been significant, we recommend their use cautiously for a military population, which maintains a high intensity of physical training.
评估了渥太华踝关节规则对X光片开具行为的影响。对80例因急性踝关节疼痛前来就诊的连续患者的病历和放射学报告进行回顾性审查,分析18项变量。22例患者符合规则标准,45例不符合。研究组(N = 67)中有10例骨折,其中3例骨折被规则漏诊。所有3例骨折均为腓骨1毫米撕脱性骨折,临床意义不大。所有临床医生应用渥太华踝关节规则,将使我们机构的X光片数量减少68%。该规则的敏感度和特异度分别为70%和73%,阳性预测值和阴性预测值分别为31.8%和93.3%。我们机构的医生未常规使用该规则。尽管将这些规则纳入我们的实践会有显著意义,但对于保持高强度体育训练的军人人群,我们建议谨慎使用。