Francis E, Marchand W, Hart M, Carter A, Schinka J, Feldman A, Ordorica P
Mental Health Services, James A. Haley Veterans Affairs Health Care System, Tampa, Florida 33612, USA.
Psychiatr Serv. 2000 Jan;51(1):92-5. doi: 10.1176/ps.51.1.92.
The effectiveness of an overnight psychiatric observation program was evaluated. The program was designed to avoid unnecessary hospitalization of patients experiencing acute psychiatric crises.
Of 110 patients admitted to the observation unit at a Veterans Affairs medical center over a six-month period in 1996, the charts of 92 patients were retrospectively reviewed. Characteristics of patients referred to the program were documented, inpatient hospitalization rates and suicide rates in the six-month periods before and after admission to the observation unit were examined, and variables related to the need for hospitalization immediately after observation were explored.
Most of the 92 patients (98 percent) were referred from the medical center's emergency room. At the time of observation, 80 percent of the patients were unemployed, 55 percent expressed suicidal or homicidal ideation, 49 percent were intoxicated or at risk for alcohol withdrawal, and 41 percent were homeless. The most frequent psychiatric diagnosis was substance abuse or dependence (77 percent). The large majority of patients (88 percent) were referred the next day to other outpatient programs for follow-up and treatment, which avoided costly inpatient treatment. In the six months before admission to the observation program, the mean number of inpatient psychiatric bed days was 9.8, compared with 2.7 days in the six-month period after discharge from the observation program. No increase in suicide gestures or attempts was noted among the patients. No variables significantly predicted admission to inpatient care after the observation period.
Overnight observation programs may provide a cost-effective alternative to traditional inpatient treatment for some individuals with psychiatric disorders.
评估一项夜间精神病观察项目的有效性。该项目旨在避免对经历急性精神病危机的患者进行不必要的住院治疗。
回顾性审查了1996年六个月期间入住退伍军人事务医疗中心观察病房的110例患者中的92例患者的病历。记录了转介至该项目的患者特征,检查了入住观察病房前后六个月期间的住院率和自杀率,并探讨了与观察后立即住院需求相关的变量。
92例患者中的大多数(98%)是从医疗中心的急诊室转介而来的。观察时,80%的患者失业,55%的患者表达了自杀或杀人意念,49%的患者醉酒或有酒精戒断风险,41%的患者无家可归。最常见的精神科诊断是物质滥用或依赖(77%)。绝大多数患者(88%)在第二天被转介至其他门诊项目进行随访和治疗,从而避免了昂贵的住院治疗。在进入观察项目前的六个月里,精神科住院病床日的平均数为9.8天,而从观察项目出院后的六个月期间为2.7天。患者中未发现自杀姿态或企图增加。观察期后,没有变量能显著预测住院治疗的入院情况。
对于一些患有精神疾病的个体,夜间观察项目可能是传统住院治疗的一种经济有效的替代方案。