Helminen S E, Vehkalahti M, Lammi R, Ketomäki T M, Murtomaa H
Department of Oral Public Health, Institute of Dentistry, University of Helsinki, Finland.
Community Dent Health. 1999 Dec;16(4):250-5.
To evaluate dentists' real-life decisions as to mode of preventive treatment in adolescents and young adults, in relation to these patients' oral-health status, and to the dentists' characteristics.
A random sample of 206 adolescents and 239 young adults (mean ages 13 and 27 years) produced 411 (92%) individual oral health records providing data on actual clinical examinations and treatment courses carried out by 56 dentists in one administrative unit of the Finnish public oral health service during 1994-1996.
Preventive measures were defined as active and passive, active including any kind of motivation or instructions given to a patient concerning home self-care, and passive prevention being topical application of fluoride.
More adolescents had received both active and passive prevention than had young adults (active: 27% vs. 20%; passive: 85% vs. 70%). Of adolescents, 7% and of young adults 25% were given no preventive treatment. The mean number of active preventive measures per adolescent during the treatment course was 0.3 and of passive measures 1.0; for young adults 0.2 and 0.8, respectively. A subject's oral health status made no significant difference in active prevention given. Active measures were more frequently given to all patients by male dentists, 35% vs. 22% (P < 0.02), and passive measures by females, 82% vs. 52% (P < 0.001). The odds of active prevention for adolescents were 7.4 comparing male dentists to female; of passive 13.8 comparing female to male.
Dentists should be motivated to make considered treatment decisions on preventive treatment.
评估牙医针对青少年和青年成人预防性治疗方式所做出的实际决策,这些决策与这些患者的口腔健康状况以及牙医的特征之间的关系。
从206名青少年和239名青年成人(平均年龄分别为13岁和27岁)中随机抽取样本,得到411份(92%)个人口腔健康记录,这些记录提供了1994 - 1996年期间芬兰公共口腔卫生服务一个行政单位的56名牙医所进行的实际临床检查和治疗过程的数据。
预防性措施分为主动和被动两种,主动措施包括给予患者任何关于家庭自我护理的激励或指导,被动预防是局部应用氟化物。
接受主动和被动预防的青少年比青年成人更多(主动:27%对20%;被动:85%对70%)。青少年中7%、青年成人中25%未接受任何预防性治疗。在治疗过程中,每个青少年接受的主动预防性措施平均数量为0.3,被动措施为1.0;青年成人分别为0.2和0.8。受试者的口腔健康状况在给予的主动预防方面没有显著差异。男性牙医对所有患者给予主动措施更为频繁,分别为35%对22%(P < 0.02),女性牙医给予被动措施更为频繁,分别为82%对52%(P < 0.001)。男性牙医与女性牙医相比,青少年接受主动预防的几率为7.4;女性与男性相比,接受被动预防的几率为13.8。
应激励牙医在预防性治疗方面做出深思熟虑的治疗决策。