Fernando I N
Birmingham Oncology Centre, University Hospital NHS Trust, UK.
Clin Oncol (R Coll Radiol). 2000;12(3):158-65. doi: 10.1053/clon.2000.9143.
Several factors, including T stage, nodal involvement, grade, the presence of lymphovascular invasion, and possibly involved or close surgical margins, have been found to affect local recurrence after mastectomy. The majority of recurrences will occur in the first 5 years and 50% of patients will have metastatic disease at the time of recurrence. Early studies on the use of adjuvant radiotherapy are difficult to interpret owing to poor radiotherapy techniques, inadequate dose or a variety of confounding variables within a particular trial. More recent reports have confirmed that adjuvant radiotherapy will reduce the risk of local recurrence and in tumours of <5 cm with involved nodes, produce a reduction in breast cancer deaths. Improvements in breast cancer mortality may however be counterbalanced by increases in cardiac events and deaths caused by second malignancies. This stresses the importance of using megavoltage irradiation and avoiding excess cardiac doses particularly when treating left-sided tumours. Adjuvant radiotherapy combined with tamoxifen has been shown to produce an improvement in both local control and survival in postmenopausal node-positive patients who have undergone mastectomy. Adjuvant radiation combined with systemic chemotherapy has a significant effect on local recurrence and probably on survival in node-positive patients after mastectomy. There is little controversy over its role in patients with tumours >5 cm, with more than four nodes involved or with one to three nodes with extracapsular extension, or in those in whom axillary surgery has been deemed inadequate (i.e. <10 nodes). Debate still exists concerning T1/T2, G1/G2 tumours with only one to three nodes involved when the axillary surgery has been satisfactory (>10 nodes). The ongoing Intergroup trial may answer this question but until then other factors such as tumour grade and the presence of lymphovascular invasion can be included in the equation to determine which of the patients in the latter group should receive postoperative radiotherapy. Controversy still exists about what fields should be irradiated and in particular whether the supraclavicular fossa and internal mammary node chain should be included in adjuvant therapy. The EORTC is presently conducting a randomized trial, which should give us the answer. Treatment at relapse on the chest wall may require a combination of surgery, radiotherapy and chemotherapy, depending on previous therapy. If radiotherapy has not previously been used, then wide-field irradiation should be administered, including both chest wall and supraclavicular fossa with or without the axilla, depending on the extent of previous axillary surgery and the risk of lymphoedema. Re-irradiation after radical adjuvant radiotherapy can be considered only for selected patients when an adequate discussion with them has taken place with regard to the relative benefits versus toxicity.
包括T分期、淋巴结受累情况、分级、淋巴管浸润情况以及可能存在的手术切缘受累或切缘接近等在内的多种因素,已被发现会影响乳房切除术后的局部复发。大多数复发会在头5年内发生,50%的患者在复发时会出现转移性疾病。早期关于辅助放疗应用的研究难以解读,原因在于放疗技术欠佳、剂量不足或特定试验中存在多种混杂变量。最近的报告证实,辅助放疗可降低局部复发风险,对于肿瘤<5 cm且有淋巴结受累的患者,可降低乳腺癌死亡率。然而,乳腺癌死亡率的改善可能会被心脏事件增加以及第二原发恶性肿瘤导致的死亡所抵消。这凸显了使用兆伏级放疗并避免过高心脏剂量的重要性,尤其是在治疗左侧肿瘤时。辅助放疗联合他莫昔芬已被证明可改善绝经后淋巴结阳性且已接受乳房切除术患者的局部控制和生存率。辅助放疗联合全身化疗对乳房切除术后淋巴结阳性患者的局部复发有显著影响,可能对生存率也有影响。对于肿瘤>5 cm、有四个以上淋巴结受累、有一至三个淋巴结伴有包膜外扩展的患者,或腋窝手术被认为不充分(即<10个淋巴结)的患者,其作用几乎没有争议。对于腋窝手术满意(>10个淋巴结)但仅一至三个淋巴结受累的T1/T2、G1/G2肿瘤患者,仍存在争议。正在进行的多组间试验可能会回答这个问题,但在此之前,肿瘤分级和淋巴管浸润情况等其他因素可纳入考量,以确定后一组中的哪些患者应接受术后放疗。关于应照射哪些区域,特别是辅助治疗是否应包括锁骨上窝和乳内淋巴结链,仍存在争议。欧洲癌症研究与治疗组织(EORTC)目前正在进行一项随机试验,应该会给我们答案。胸壁复发时的治疗可能需要根据既往治疗情况联合手术、放疗和化疗。如果之前未使用过放疗,那么应进行广野照射,包括胸壁和锁骨上窝,根据既往腋窝手术范围及淋巴水肿风险决定是否包括腋窝。仅在与选定患者就相对获益与毒性进行充分讨论后,才考虑在根治性辅助放疗后进行再次放疗。