Pinto J L, López Lavid C, Badia X, Coma A, Benavides A
Universitat Pompeu Fabra, Barcelona.
Med Clin (Barc). 2000;114 Suppl 3:62-7.
Assessment of cost and effectiveness in highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) in HIV asymptomatic patients.
A cohort of several asymptomatic HIV-infected patients were observed under real practice and treated with two nucleosid analogues (AN) of which therapy was modified. A protease inhibitor (PI) was added and at least one AN was changed (or not), following the current clinical recommendations (1997). Data on direct cost (drug cost, visits and clinical procedures) were then recorded both three and six months after the beginning of the study. Data on effectiveness (percentage of patients with undetectable levels of viral load) and quality of life were next measured according to the EuroQol, and recorded at the same time. All patients used a monthly diary to keep record of resource consumption and quality of life progress.
All treatment regimens were effective in lowering the viral load and improve quality of life. The less expensive HAART was AZT + 3TC + IND (1,037,757 pesetas) and AZT + ddl + IND (1,045,339 pesetas), but both were the least effective to reduce patient's viral load to undetectable levels (52.7 and 57.7% respectively); meanwhile d4T + 3TC + IND (1,188,177 pesetas) and d4T + ddl + IND (1,212,285 pesetas) were more expensive but more effective (67.9 and 66% respectively). Cost-effectiveness ratios ranged between 9,896 and 13,122 pesetas. There was no statistically significant differences in quality of life among the different HAART regimens.
HAART implementation is effective in reducing patients' viral load to undetectable levels and to slightly improve their quality of life after six months. Costs and effectiveness vary according to the type of HAART treatment used.
评估高效抗逆转录病毒疗法(HAART)在无症状HIV患者中的成本及效果。
在实际临床实践中观察了一组无症状HIV感染患者,给予两种核苷类似物(AN)进行治疗,并对治疗方案进行调整。按照当前临床建议(1997年)添加一种蛋白酶抑制剂(PI),且至少更换一种(或不更换)AN。在研究开始后的三个月和六个月记录直接成本数据(药物成本、就诊及临床检查费用)。接下来根据欧洲五维度健康量表测量有效性数据(病毒载量检测不到的患者百分比)及生活质量,并同时记录。所有患者使用月度日志记录资源消耗及生活质量进展情况。
所有治疗方案均能有效降低病毒载量并改善生活质量。成本较低的HAART方案是齐多夫定(AZT)+拉米夫定(3TC)+茚地那韦(IND)(1,037,757比塞塔)和AZT+双脱氧肌苷(ddl)+IND(1,045,339比塞塔),但二者在将患者病毒载量降至检测不到水平方面效果最差(分别为52.7%和57.7%);同时,司他夫定(d4T)+3TC+IND(1,188,177比塞塔)和d4T+ddl+IND(1,212,285比塞塔)成本更高但效果更好(分别为67.9%和66%)。成本效益比在9,896至13,122比塞塔之间。不同HAART方案在生活质量方面无统计学显著差异。
实施HAART可有效将患者病毒载量降至检测不到水平,并在六个月后略微改善其生活质量。成本和效果因所用HAART治疗类型而异。