Nisenbaum R, Jones A, Jones J, Reeves W
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, GA, USA
Ann Epidemiol. 2000 Oct 1;10(7):458. doi: 10.1016/s1047-2797(00)00119-8.
To determine the effect of chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) illness duration and onset type on the likelihood of reporting a symptom during successive follow-up periods.METHODS: In 1997, a two-phase RDD survey in Wichita, Kansas, was conducted to estimate the prevalence of CFS. Phase I identified 56,154 respondents 18-69 years of age and screened for severe fatigue, extreme tiredness or exhaustion lasting for 1 month or longer. In phase II an equal number of fatigued (n = 7,176) and randomly selected non-fatigued subjects were asked about 8 CFS and 13 non-CFS symptoms, as well as the presence of specific medical and psychiatric conditions. Eligible respondents were clinically evaluated to establish CFS diagnosis. Phase II respondents were re-contacted at 12- (n = 4,331) and 24-months (n = 4,266) for additional follow-up and diagnosis. In this study we considered symptoms reported as being present most of the time during each successive observation period. Generalized estimating equations were used to model symptoms over time and to address study questions. Such a model accounts for correlations among repeated symptoms for each subject. We used an auto-regressive structure for the correlation matrix, assuming the correlations between each pair of repeated symptoms should decrease as the time between symptoms increased.RESULTS: There were 74 CFS patients who had been ill for 1 to 20 years (median = 6.3 years). Among these, 46 reported gradual and 28 reported sudden onset. Symptoms fluctuated over the course of illness. However, only stomach pain (non-CFS symptom) was more likely to be reported as duration of illness increased (p < 0.05). There was no association between onset type and the likelihood of reporting a symptom during an interview, except that chills and severe headaches were more likely to be reported by sudden cases.CONCLUSIONS: The likelihood of expressing CFS and non-CFS symptom "most of the time" is the same across years of illness. More analyses are warranted to consider expression of symptoms for >/=6 months and severe symptoms.
确定慢性疲劳综合征(CFS)的病程和起病类型对连续随访期间报告症状可能性的影响。
1997年,在堪萨斯州威奇托市进行了一项两阶段的随机数字拨号(RDD)调查,以估计CFS的患病率。第一阶段确定了56154名年龄在18 - 69岁之间的受访者,并对持续1个月或更长时间的严重疲劳、极度疲倦或疲惫进行筛查。在第二阶段,对数量相等的疲劳者(n = 7176)和随机选择的非疲劳者询问了8种CFS症状和13种非CFS症状,以及特定的医学和精神状况。对符合条件的受访者进行临床评估以确立CFS诊断。在12个月(n = 4331)和24个月(n = 4266)时再次联系第二阶段的受访者进行额外随访和诊断。在本研究中,我们考虑了在每个连续观察期内大部分时间报告存在的症状。使用广义估计方程对症状随时间变化进行建模并解决研究问题。这样的模型考虑了每个受试者重复症状之间的相关性。我们对相关矩阵使用自回归结构,假设每对重复症状之间的相关性应随着症状之间时间间隔的增加而降低。
有74名CFS患者患病1至20年(中位数 = 6.3年)。其中,46名报告为逐渐起病,28名报告为突然起病。症状在病程中波动。然而,只有胃痛(非CFS症状)随着病程延长更有可能被报告(p < 0.05)。起病类型与访谈期间报告症状的可能性之间没有关联,除了寒战和严重头痛在突然起病的病例中更有可能被报告。
在患病的数年中,“大部分时间”表达CFS和非CFS症状的可能性是相同的。有必要进行更多分析以考虑症状持续≥6个月和严重症状的表达情况。