Rosenheck R
VA Northeast Program Evaluation Center, VA Connecticut Healthcare System, West Haven 06516, USA.
Health Serv Res. 2000 Oct;35(4):777-90.
To evaluate the relationship between the implementation of community-based primary care clinics and improved access to general health care and/or mental health care, in both the general population and among people with disabling mental illness.
The 69 new community-based primary care clinics in underserved areas, established by the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) between the last quarter of FY 1995 and the second quarter of FY 1998, including the 21 new clinics with a specialty mental health care component.
VA inpatient and outpatient workload files, 1990 U.S. Census data, and VA Compensation and Pension files were used to determine the proportion of all veterans, and the proportion of disabled veterans, living in each U.S. county who used VA general health care services and VA mental health services before and after these clinics began operation.
Analysis of covariance was used to compare changes, from late FY 1995 through early FY 1998, in access to VA services in counties in which new primary care clinics were located, in counties in which clinics that included specialized mental health components were located, and for comparison, in other U.S. counties, adjusting for potentially confounding factors.
Counties in which new clinics were located showed a significant increase from the FY 1995-FY 1998 study dates in the proportion of veterans who used general VA health care services. This increase was almost twice as large as that observed in comparison counties (4.2% vs. 2.5%: F = 12.6, df = 1,3118, p = .0004). However, the introduction of these clinics was not associated with a greater use of specialty VA mental health services in the general veteran population, or of either general health care services or mental health services among veterans who received VA compensation for psychiatric disorders. In contrast, in counties with new clinics that included a mental health component the proportion of veterans who used VA mental health services increased to almost three times the proportion in comparison counties (0.87% vs. 0.31%: F = 8.3, df = 1,3091, p = .004).
Community-based primary care clinics can improve access to general health care services, but a specialty mental health care component appears to be needed to improve access to mental health services.
评估在普通人群以及患有致残性精神疾病的人群中,社区基层医疗诊所的设立与获得普通医疗保健和/或精神卫生保健机会改善之间的关系。
美国退伍军人事务部(VA)在1995财年最后一个季度至1998财年第二季度期间,在服务不足地区设立了69家新的社区基层医疗诊所,其中包括21家设有精神卫生专科护理部门的新诊所。
VA住院和门诊工作量文件、1990年美国人口普查数据以及VA补偿和抚恤金文件,用于确定居住在美国各县的所有退伍军人以及残疾退伍军人在这些诊所开始运营之前和之后使用VA普通医疗保健服务和VA精神卫生服务的比例。
采用协方差分析来比较1995财年末至1998财年初期间,新基层医疗诊所所在县、设有精神卫生专科部门的诊所所在县以及作为对照的其他美国县中,退伍军人获得VA服务的变化情况,并对潜在的混杂因素进行调整。
新诊所所在县在1995财年至1998财年研究期间,使用VA普通医疗保健服务的退伍军人比例显著增加。这一增幅几乎是对照县的两倍(4.2%对2.5%:F = 12.6,自由度 = 1,3118,p = .0004)。然而,这些诊所的设立与普通退伍军人更多地使用VA精神卫生专科服务无关,也与因精神疾病获得VA补偿的退伍军人使用普通医疗保健服务或精神卫生服务的情况无关。相比之下, 在设有精神卫生部门的新诊所所在县,使用VA精神卫生服务的退伍军人比例增加到对照县的近三倍(0.87%对0.31%:F = 8.3,自由度 = 1,3091,p = .004)。
社区基层医疗诊所可以改善获得普通医疗保健服务的机会,但似乎需要一个精神卫生专科护理部门来改善获得精神卫生服务的机会。