Knight C M, Moule P, Desbottes Z
University of the West of England, Faculty of Health and Social Care, (Glenside Campus), Blackberry Hill, Stapleton, Bristol BS16 1DD, UK.
Nurse Educ Today. 2000 Feb;20(2):116-22. doi: 10.1054/nedt.1999.0374.
Since the introduction of the Diploma in Higher Education in Nursing Studies (Dip HE NS) at this Faculty, course evaluations have consistently reported students' fears and apprehensions which result from their perceived lack of practical ability. Their experiences are supported by accounts from other nursing faculty (Elkan et al. 1993, Jowett & Walton 1994). In 1994, following analysis of course evaluations and a review of the literature on skill acquisition, experiential skills teaching was resumed within the faculty setting. This was after a period in the late 1980s when the cultural thinking was that 'practice suites' were to be frowned upon, and that skills were best taught in practice placements. Despite rigorous literature reviews (Love et al. 1989, Knight 1996) there appears to be no research to support the dismantling of practice suites. A structured approach to teaching skills now takes place in a purpose built Skills Centre. The approach used is based on a model by Gentile (1972), which is founded upon the theoretical principles of skill acquisition. It provides a blueprint for the teaching and transference of skills, and implicit in the model is the use of skill analysis. This involves demonstration of a skill by the facilitator, followed by analysis of it by the student into its component parts; this is followed by practise. The authors were concerned, however, that the use of skill analysis to teach skills should not be reduced to a presentation of a succession of isolated tasks. The authors were also aware that a nursing skill often has a tendency to be viewed purely within the psychomotor domain, with little attention paid to the knowledge base which underpins the skill. This viewpoint may contribute to the notion of a theory-practice gap. In response to these concerns, the authors have developed the Skill Grid. The grid incorporates skill analysis with Carper's theoretical framework: Fundamental Ways of Knowing (Carper 1975). The authors believe that knowledge which exemplifies nursing practice has many dimensions, and that it is crucial for students to explore the derivation of knowledge from an ontological perspective. Carper's framework will enable consideration of knowledge originating not only from empirical, but also aesthetic, personal and ethical sources. An essential feature of the grid is the attempt to link knowledge with practice by demonstrating how Carper's framework, which identifies sources of knowledge, can form the basis for the acquisition of skill. The authors have also incorporated problem-based learning into their teaching, so that the skills are practised within a patient/client orientated situation.
自从该学院引入高等教育护理专业文凭课程(Dip HE NS)以来,课程评估一直反映出学生因感觉自己缺乏实践能力而产生的恐惧和担忧。其他护理学院的报告也证实了他们的经历(埃尔坎等人,1993年;乔伊特和沃尔顿,1994年)。1994年,在对课程评估进行分析并回顾了有关技能习得的文献之后,该学院重新开始了体验式技能教学。这是在20世纪80年代后期之后,当时的文化观念认为“实践套房”是不受欢迎的,技能最好在实习岗位上教授。尽管进行了严格的文献综述(洛夫等人,1989年;奈特,1996年),但似乎没有研究支持拆除实践套房。现在,技能教学在一个专门建造的技能中心以结构化的方式进行。所采用的方法基于根蒂莱(1972年)的模型,该模型建立在技能习得的理论原则之上。它为技能的教学和传授提供了一个蓝图,该模型中隐含着技能分析的运用。这包括由指导者演示一项技能,然后由学生将其分析成各个组成部分;接下来是练习。然而,作者担心将技能分析用于技能教学不应简化为一系列孤立任务的呈现。作者还意识到,护理技能往往倾向于仅在心理运动领域内被看待,而很少关注支撑该技能的知识基础。这种观点可能导致理论与实践脱节的观念。针对这些担忧,作者开发了技能网格。该网格将技能分析与卡珀的理论框架:《认知的基本方式》(卡珀,1975年)相结合。作者认为,体现护理实践的知识有多个维度,让学生从本体论的角度探索知识的来源至关重要。卡珀的框架将使人们不仅能够考虑源于经验的知识,还能考虑源于美学、个人和伦理的知识。该网格的一个基本特征是试图通过展示卡珀的识别知识来源的框架如何能够成为技能习得的基础,将知识与实践联系起来。作者还将基于问题的学习纳入他们的教学中,以便在以患者/服务对象为导向的情境中练习技能。