Tol J L, Verheyen C P, van Dijk C N
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Academic Medical Centre, University of Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
J Bone Joint Surg Br. 2001 Jan;83(1):9-13. doi: 10.1302/0301-620x.83b1.10571.
We performed a prospective study to assess the long-term outcome of 57 arthroscopic debridement procedures carried out to treat anterior impingement in the ankle. Using preoperative radiographs, we grouped patients according to the extent of their osteoarthritis (OA). The symptoms of those with grade-0 changes could be attributed to anterior soft-tissue impingement alone. Patients with grade-I disease had both anterior soft-tissue and osteophytic impingement, but no narrowing of the joint space. In those with grade-II OA, narrowing of the joint space was accompanied by osteophytic impingement. Radiographs taken before and after operation and at follow-up were compared to assess the recurrence of osteophytes and the progression of narrowing of the joint space. At a mean follow-up of 6.5 years (5 to 8) all patients without OA had excellent or good results. There were excellent or good results in 77% of patients with grade-I OA, despite partial or complete recurrence of osteophytes in two-thirds. In most patients with grade-II OA, narrowing of the joint space had not progressed at follow-up. There was a notable improvement in pain in these patients, 53% of whom had excellent or good results. Although some osteophytes recurred, at long-term follow-up arthroscopic excision of soft-tissue overgrowths and osteophytes proved to be an effective way of treating anterior impingement of the ankle in patients who had no narrowing of the joint space.
我们进行了一项前瞻性研究,以评估57例为治疗踝关节前撞击而实施的关节镜清创手术的长期疗效。利用术前X光片,我们根据骨关节炎(OA)的程度对患者进行分组。0级改变的患者症状仅归因于前侧软组织撞击。I级疾病患者既有前侧软组织撞击又有骨赘撞击,但关节间隙无变窄。II级OA患者关节间隙变窄伴有骨赘撞击。比较手术前后及随访时拍摄的X光片,以评估骨赘复发情况及关节间隙变窄的进展。平均随访6.5年(5至8年),所有无OA的患者结果为优或良。I级OA患者中有77%结果为优或良,尽管三分之二的患者骨赘部分或完全复发。大多数II级OA患者在随访时关节间隙变窄未进展。这些患者疼痛有显著改善,其中53%结果为优或良。虽然一些骨赘复发,但长期随访显示,对于关节间隙无变窄的患者,关节镜下切除软组织增生和骨赘是治疗踝关节前撞击的有效方法。