Chen H, Hardacre J M, Martin C, Lillemoe K D
Department of Surgery, The University of Wisconsin Medical School, Madison, Wisconsin 53792, USA.
J Surg Res. 2001 May 15;97(2):172-8. doi: 10.1006/jsre.2001.6135.
A comprehensive exposure to general surgery is essential for medical students pursuing careers in surgery. Occasionally, students applying for surgical residency positions must choose a subspecialty field prior to starting their residency training. Often, this decision is heavily based on their experience on various surgical clerkships.
To determine if surgical clerkships influence subspecialty choice, we surveyed medical students who interviewed for general surgery training over a 2-year period at The Johns Hopkins Hospital.
Of 211 surveys sent, 146 were returned (66%). The mean age of the students was 26 +/- 0 years with 21% being female. Students anticipating subspecialization in cardiothoracic, plastic, pediatric, and transplant surgery saw significantly more operations in their respective fields. Similar trends were seen in vascular surgery and surgical oncology. Despite the apparent differences in exposure to subspecialty operations, all students saw equal numbers of hernia repairs and laparoscopic cholecystectomies.
While medical students pursuing careers in surgery have equal exposure to general surgery, their anticipated subspecialty field highly correlated with their operative exposure to that field. Thus, medical school surgical rotations appear to highly influence subspecialty choice.
对于有志于从事外科职业的医学生而言,全面接触普通外科手术至关重要。偶尔,申请外科住院医师职位的学生在开始住院医师培训之前必须选择一个亚专业领域。通常,这一决定很大程度上基于他们在各种外科实习中的经历。
为了确定外科实习是否会影响亚专业选择,我们对在约翰霍普金斯医院接受为期两年普通外科培训面试的医学生进行了调查。
共发放211份调查问卷,回收146份(66%)。学生的平均年龄为26±0岁,其中21%为女性。预计从事心胸外科、整形外科、小儿外科和移植外科亚专业的学生在各自领域观看的手术明显更多。血管外科和外科肿瘤学也出现了类似趋势。尽管在亚专业手术的接触方面存在明显差异,但所有学生观看的疝气修补术和腹腔镜胆囊切除术数量相同。
虽然有志于从事外科职业的医学生在普通外科手术方面的接触机会均等,但他们预期的亚专业领域与他们在该领域的手术接触高度相关。因此,医学院的外科轮转似乎对亚专业选择有很大影响。