Stone R A, Youk A O, Marsh G M, Buchanich J M, McHenry M B, Smith T J
Department of Biostatistics, Graduate School of Public Health, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA 15261, USA.
J Occup Environ Med. 2001 Sep;43(9):779-92. doi: 10.1097/00043764-200109000-00007.
As part of the 1992 update of an historical cohort study of 32,110 workers employed for at least 1 year in any of 10 US fiberglass manufacturing plants, a nested case-control study was done in which data on tobacco smoking were obtained for 631 male case subjects with respiratory system cancer (RSC) and 570 control subjects matched on age and year of birth. In this more extensive analysis of the nested case-control data, we provide a detailed assessment of the most prominent findings from the initial report. We expand the scope of the analysis to consider quantitative measures of exposure to respirable fibers (RFib), formaldehyde (FOR), and silica (Sil) and consider these and other exposures together in the same model. We investigate the functional form of possible exposure-response relationships between RSC risk, RFib, and FOR. In addition, we address the statistical issues of collinearity, effect modification, and potential confounding by coexposures. All analyses are adjusted for smoking. Neither measure of exposure to RFib (average intensity of exposure or cumulative exposure) was statistically significantly associated with RSC risk in any of the hundreds of fractional polynomial models considered. This more extensive analysis has substantiated our initial finding of no apparent exposure-response relationship between RSC risk and either cumulative or average intensity of exposure to RFib at the levels experienced by these workers. This study provides some evidence of increased RSC risk among workers at the higher observed levels of average intensity of exposure to FOR and/or Sil. No positive associations were identified between RSC risk and any of the other exposures considered in this case-control study.
作为对美国10家玻璃纤维制造工厂中至少工作1年的32110名工人进行的历史性队列研究1992年更新内容的一部分,开展了一项巢式病例对照研究,收集了631名患呼吸系统癌症(RSC)的男性病例受试者和570名按年龄和出生年份匹配的对照受试者的吸烟数据。在对巢式病例对照数据进行的这项更广泛分析中,我们对初始报告中的最突出发现进行了详细评估。我们扩大了分析范围,以考虑可吸入纤维(RFib)、甲醛(FOR)和二氧化硅(Sil)暴露的定量测量,并在同一模型中综合考虑这些暴露因素和其他暴露因素。我们研究了RSC风险、RFib和FOR之间可能的暴露-反应关系的函数形式。此外,我们还解决了共暴露导致的共线性、效应修正和潜在混杂等统计问题。所有分析均对吸烟因素进行了校正。在考虑的数百个分数多项式模型中,RFib暴露的任何测量指标(平均暴露强度或累积暴露量)均与RSC风险无统计学显著关联。这项更广泛的分析证实了我们最初的发现,即在这些工人所经历的暴露水平下,RSC风险与RFib的累积暴露量或平均暴露强度之间没有明显的暴露-反应关系。这项研究提供了一些证据,表明在观察到的较高平均FOR和/或Sil暴露强度水平的工人中,RSC风险增加。在这项病例对照研究中,未发现RSC风险与所考虑的任何其他暴露因素之间存在正相关。