Hassan B S, Mockett S, Doherty M
Academic Rheumatology, Clinical Sciences Building, University of Nottingham, City Hospital, Hucknall Road, Nottingham NG5 1PB, UK.
Ann Rheum Dis. 2002 Jan;61(1):24-8. doi: 10.1136/ard.61.1.24.
To investigate whether a "standard" sized (that is, a size that would be prescribed by a physiotherapist) elastic bandage (S-bandage) around the knee of subjects with knee osteoarthritis (OA) would, in the short term (a) reduce pain, (b) improve knee joint proprioception, and (c) decrease sway in comparison with a looser (L-bandage).
In a cross over, within-subject study, 68 subjects (49 women, 19 men; mean age 67.1, range 36-87) with symptomatic and radiographic knee OA were randomly assigned to either an S-bandage or an L-bandage. Two weeks later they were assigned to the opposite bandage size. Knee pain (10 cm visual analogue scale (VAS)), knee proprioception, and static postural sway were assessed for each bandage two weeks apart. During each visit assessments were performed at baseline, after 20 minutes of bandage application, and immediately after bandage removal.
The S-bandage did not have any effect on knee pain, proprioception, or postural sway. The L-bandage reduced knee pain significantly (pre-bandage application: median VAS 4.36, IQR 3.84 -4.90; after 20 minutes of bandage application: median VAS 3.80, IQR 3.3-4.3, p<0.001), improved static postural sway (pre-bandage: median sway 4.50, IQ range 3.5-6.4; bandage applied: median sway 4.45, IQ range 3.4-6.3, p=0.027), but had no significant influence on knee proprioception.
In subjects with knee OA application of an elastic bandage around the knee can reduce knee pain and improve static postural sway. This outcome depends on the size of applied bandage.
研究对于患有膝骨关节炎(OA)的受试者,在其膝盖周围使用“标准”尺寸(即物理治疗师会开具的尺寸)的弹力绷带(S型绷带)与较宽松的(L型绷带)相比,在短期内是否会(a)减轻疼痛,(b)改善膝关节本体感觉,以及(c)减少身体摇摆。
在一项交叉的、受试者自身对照研究中,68名有症状且经影像学检查确诊为膝OA的受试者(49名女性,19名男性;平均年龄67.1岁,范围36 - 87岁)被随机分配使用S型绷带或L型绷带。两周后,他们被分配使用相反尺寸的绷带。每种绷带使用两周后,分别评估膝关节疼痛(10厘米视觉模拟量表(VAS))、膝关节本体感觉和静态姿势摇摆情况。每次就诊时,在基线、绷带使用20分钟后以及绷带拆除后立即进行评估。
S型绷带对膝关节疼痛、本体感觉或姿势摇摆没有任何影响。L型绷带显著减轻了膝关节疼痛(绷带使用前:VAS中位数4.36,四分位间距3.84 - 4.90;绷带使用20分钟后:VAS中位数3.80,四分位间距3.3 - 4.3,p<0.001),改善了静态姿势摇摆(绷带使用前:摇摆中位数4.50,四分位间距3.5 - 6.4;绷带使用后:摇摆中位数4.45,四分位间距3.4 - 6.3,p = 0.027),但对膝关节本体感觉没有显著影响。
对于患有膝OA的受试者,在膝盖周围使用弹力绷带可以减轻膝关节疼痛并改善静态姿势摇摆。这一结果取决于所使用绷带的尺寸。