Dennis Cindy-Lee
Faculty of Nursing, University of Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
J Obstet Gynecol Neonatal Nurs. 2002 Jan-Feb;31(1):12-32. doi: 10.1111/j.1552-6909.2002.tb00019.x.
To review the literature on breastfeeding initiation and duration and to delineate effective strategies for promoting positive breastfeeding behaviors.
Computerized searches on MEDLINE, CINAHL, and the Cochrane Library.
Articles from indexed journals relevant to the objective and published after 1990 (except for classic findings) were reviewed. Although a myriad of pertinent articles was located, referenced citations were limited to three per point. When article selection was required for a specific point, preferences were given to (a) randomized controlled trials; (b) meta-analyses; (c) studies with the largest, most representative samples; and (d) investigations conducted in North America.
Data were extracted and organized under the following headings: benefits of breastfeeding, breastfeeding initiation and duration, personal characteristics, attitudinal and intrapersonal characteristics, hospital policies and intrapartum experience, sources of support, breastfeeding interventions, and review implications.
Although the health benefits of breastfeeding are well documented and initiation rates have increased over the past 20 years, most mothers wean before the recommended 6-months postpartum because of perceived difficulties with breastfeeding rather than due to maternal choice. Women least likely to breastfeed are those who are young, have a low income, belong to an ethnic minority, are unsupported, are employed full-time, decided to breastfeed during or late in pregnancy, have negative attitudes toward breastfeeding, and have low confidence in their ability to breastfeed. Support from the mother's partner or a nonprofessional greatly increases the likelihood of positive breastfeeding behaviors. Health care professionals can be a negative source of support if their lack of knowledge results in inaccurate or inconsistent advice. Furthermore, a number of hospital routines are potentially detrimental to breastfeeding. Although professional interventions that enhance the usual care mothers receive increase breastfeeding duration to 2 months, these supportive strategies have limited long-term effects. Peer support interventions also promote positive breastfeeding behaviors and should be considered.
A promising intervention is the complementation of professional services with peer support from a mother experienced in breastfeeding. This lay support appears to be an effective intervention with socially disadvantaged women.
回顾关于母乳喂养起始和持续时间的文献,并阐述促进积极母乳喂养行为的有效策略。
对MEDLINE、CINAHL和Cochrane图书馆进行计算机检索。
回顾1990年后发表的(经典研究结果除外)与该目的相关的索引期刊文章。尽管找到了大量相关文章,但每个要点的参考文献限于三篇。当特定要点需要进行文章选择时,优先考虑:(a)随机对照试验;(b)荟萃分析;(c)样本量最大、最具代表性的研究;以及(d)在北美进行的调查。
数据按照以下标题进行提取和整理:母乳喂养的益处、母乳喂养起始和持续时间、个人特征、态度和个人内在特征、医院政策和分娩期经历、支持来源、母乳喂养干预措施以及综述启示。
尽管母乳喂养对健康的益处已有充分记录,且在过去20年中起始率有所上升,但大多数母亲在产后6个月的推荐时长之前就停止母乳喂养了,原因是她们认为母乳喂养存在困难,而非出于母亲自身的选择。最不可能进行母乳喂养的女性包括年轻、低收入、少数族裔、缺乏支持、全职工作、在孕期中晚期才决定母乳喂养、对母乳喂养持消极态度以及对自己母乳喂养能力缺乏信心的女性。母亲的伴侣或非专业人士的支持会大大增加积极母乳喂养行为的可能性。如果医护人员缺乏知识,导致提供的建议不准确或不一致,他们可能成为负面的支持来源。此外,一些医院常规做法可能对母乳喂养有害。尽管增强母亲常规护理的专业干预措施可将母乳喂养持续时间延长至2个月,但这些支持性策略的长期效果有限。同伴支持干预措施也能促进积极的母乳喂养行为,应予以考虑。
一种有前景的干预措施是将专业服务与来自有母乳喂养经验的母亲的同伴支持相结合。这种非专业支持似乎是对社会弱势群体有效的干预措施。