Powell J, Kitchen N, Heslin J, Greenwood R
Department of Psychology, Goldsmiths College, Lewisham Way, New Cross, London SE14 6NW, UK.
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 2002 Jun;72(6):772-81. doi: 10.1136/jnnp.72.6.772.
To investigate (1) the prevalence of various aspects of cognitive and psychosocial dysfunction, including post-traumatic stress symptoms, over nine months after subarachnoid haemorrhage (SAH); (2) whether SAH is preceded by increased life stress; (3) to what extent adverse outcomes may be predicted from preillness life stress, early neurological impairment, age, and sex; and (4) relations between emotional and functional outcomes.
52 patients with good neurological recovery after surgery for SAH were each matched for age, sex, and occupation with a healthy control participant. SAH patients were assessed three and nine months postdischarge on measures of cognitive functioning, mood, and social functioning. Objective stressors and subjective life change during the preceding year were rated retrospectively. Controls completed measures of mood and social functioning once only.
Compared with controls, SAH patients showed increased mood disturbance, subtle cognitive impairment, and abnormally low independence and participation on measures of social functioning. 60% showed clinically significant post-traumatic stress symptomatology (intrusive thoughts or avoidance of reminders) at three months and 30% at nine months. Independence in activities of daily living was greatly reduced in half to a third of the sample at both three and nine months. Productive employment was below the 10th percentile of the control group for 75% of patients at three months and for 56% at nine months; this outcome could not be predicted from selected demographic, premorbid, or clinical variables but dependence on others for organisational activities was predicted by impaired prose recall. Mood at nine months was strongly predicted by prior mental health problems, poor physical health, dysphasia, and impaired prose recall at three months. There was no evidence of an abnormally high level of stressful life events in the year before SAH, although patients rated their subjective level of stress in this period slightly more highly than did the control participants.
These findings highlight the need for structured support and treatment after surgery for SAH to reduce persisting mood disturbance and increase independence and participation.
调查(1)蛛网膜下腔出血(SAH)九个月后认知和心理社会功能障碍各方面的患病率,包括创伤后应激症状;(2)SAH之前生活压力是否增加;(3)疾病前生活压力、早期神经功能损害、年龄和性别在多大程度上可预测不良结局;(4)情绪和功能结局之间的关系。
52例SAH手术后神经功能恢复良好的患者,在年龄、性别和职业方面与一名健康对照参与者进行匹配。SAH患者在出院后三个月和九个月接受认知功能、情绪和社会功能测量评估。回顾性评定前一年的客观应激源和主观生活变化。对照组仅完成一次情绪和社会功能测量。
与对照组相比,SAH患者在情绪困扰增加、存在细微认知障碍以及社会功能测量中独立性和参与度异常低下方面表现明显。60%的患者在三个月时出现具有临床意义的创伤后应激症状(侵入性思维或回避提示物),九个月时为30%。在三个月和九个月时,样本中分别有一半至三分之一的患者日常生活活动独立性大幅降低。75%的患者在三个月时生产性就业低于对照组第10百分位数,九个月时为56%;这一结局无法从选定的人口统计学、病前或临床变量预测,但散文回忆受损可预测在组织活动方面对他人的依赖。九个月时的情绪强烈地由既往心理健康问题、身体健康不佳、言语困难以及三个月时的散文回忆受损所预测。没有证据表明SAH前一年生活应激事件水平异常高,尽管患者在此期间对主观应激水平的评分略高于对照参与者。
这些发现凸显了SAH手术后需要结构化的支持和治疗,以减少持续的情绪困扰并提高独立性和参与度。