Robert Philippe
Memory Centre UEC, Centre Hospitalier universitaire de Nice, France.
Curr Med Res Opin. 2002;18(3):156-71. doi: 10.1185/030079902125000561.
Behavioural and psychological symptoms of dementia (BPSD) are among the most distressing manifestations of dementia and result in considerable social and economic costs. Practical, non-pharmacological approaches such as environmental and behavioural changes may provide some benefit for patients in managing mild BPSD. In addition, various pharmacological approaches to treatment have been employed, such as neuroleptics and atypical antipsychotics, which differ in neurochemical target and clinical effectiveness. Growing evidence suggests that the neurobiological basis of BPSD in Alzheimer's disease (AD) and related dementias is a loss of cholinergic neurones and a resultant decline in acetylcholine (ACh) in brain regions which regulate behavioural and emotional responses, such as the limbic system. This cholinergic deficit can be partly corrected by inhibiting cholinesterase enzymes (ChEs). Studies of ChE inhibitors have shown positive effects to improve or stabilise existing BPSD and delay the emergence of new behavioural symptoms. In placebo-controlled studies, donepezil has reported efficacy in non-institutionalised moderate to moderately severe patients over a period of 24 weeks, but has failed to demonstrate efficacy in mild to moderate AD and in institutionalised patients with severe disease. Galantamine has been shown to delay the onset of BPSD in mild to moderate AD patients in one placebo-controlled study, and improve BPSD in a similar study of patients with cerebrovascular disease or probable vascular dementia. Studies with rivastigmine have shown efficacy in placebo-controlled studies of mild to moderately severe AD and in patients with Lewy body variant AD. Institutionalised patients with severe disease also show symptomatic benefits in BPSD with rivastigmine, resulting in a reduction in concomitant psychoactive medication use. Symptom complexes responding to ChE inhibitors appear to differ - all agents improve apathy, depression and anxiety, while rivastigmine additionally improves hallucinations and delusions, possibility as a result of dual inhibition of acetylcholinesterase and butyrylcholinesterase. The presence of hallucinations has been shown to predict response to rivastigmine. Accumulating data from studies of ChE inhibitors suggest that early intervention and long-term treatment, in addition to providing cognitive benefits, improves BPSD and offers potential to enhance quality of life. Differences seen between the agents in terms of efficacy in BPSD, tolerability and safety profiles may be the result of differences in neuropharmacological profiles.
痴呆的行为和心理症状(BPSD)是痴呆最令人痛苦的表现之一,会导致巨大的社会和经济成本。一些切实可行的非药物方法,如环境和行为改变,可能对管理轻度BPSD的患者有一定益处。此外,已经采用了各种药物治疗方法,如抗精神病药和非典型抗精神病药,它们在神经化学靶点和临床疗效方面存在差异。越来越多的证据表明,阿尔茨海默病(AD)及相关痴呆中BPSD的神经生物学基础是胆碱能神经元的丧失以及调节行为和情绪反应的脑区(如边缘系统)中乙酰胆碱(ACh)的相应减少。这种胆碱能缺陷可以通过抑制胆碱酯酶(ChE)部分得到纠正。ChE抑制剂的研究表明,其对改善或稳定现有的BPSD以及延缓新行为症状的出现有积极作用。在安慰剂对照研究中,多奈哌齐在24周的时间里对非机构化的中度至中度重度患者显示出疗效,但在轻度至中度AD患者和重度疾病的机构化患者中未能证明其疗效。在一项安慰剂对照研究中,加兰他敏已被证明可延缓轻度至中度AD患者BPSD的发作,并且在一项针对脑血管疾病或可能的血管性痴呆患者的类似研究中可改善BPSD。卡巴拉汀的研究在轻度至中度重度AD的安慰剂对照研究以及路易体变异型AD患者中显示出疗效。重度疾病的机构化患者使用卡巴拉汀在BPSD方面也显示出症状改善,从而减少了同时使用的精神活性药物。对ChE抑制剂有反应的症状复合体似乎有所不同——所有药物都能改善冷漠、抑郁和焦虑,而卡巴拉汀还能改善幻觉和妄想,这可能是由于对乙酰胆碱酯酶和丁酰胆碱酯酶的双重抑制作用。幻觉的存在已被证明可预测对卡巴拉汀的反应。来自ChE抑制剂研究的累积数据表明,早期干预和长期治疗除了提供认知益处外,还能改善BPSD并有可能提高生活质量。在BPSD的疗效、耐受性和安全性方面观察到的药物差异可能是神经药理学特征差异的结果。