Hervás Benito I, Ribes Cuenca J, Pérez Velasco R, Barceló Iranzo M, Burguera Hernández J A
Servicio de Medicina Nuclear, Hospital Universitario La Fe, Valencia, Spain.
Rev Esp Med Nucl. 2002 Jul;21(4):281-5. doi: 10.1016/s0212-6982(02)72089-2.
We have studied three women (66,72 and 72 years) with Parkinson's disease of 11, 6 and 21 years of evolution and drug-resistant severe depressive episodes treated with electroconvulsive therapy (ECT). We have performed a brain SPECT (99mTc-HMPAO) before and after the ECT. The clinical improvement of the severe depressive episodes were measured using the Hamilton score. The first patient did not experience any clinical improvement (Hamilton score 42 to 42). In this patient the brain SPECT before treatment presented a reduced perfusion in the posterior parietal region, anterior cingulate cortex and medial frontal and parietal cortex. After the treatment, the brain SPECT did not present significant variations. The second patient presented a moderate clinical improvement (Hamilton score 46 to 36) and also presented moderate improvement in the neurological symptoms. The brain SPECT before the treatment showed reduced perfusion in the left temporal cortex and medium-posterior parietal cortex. After the treatment, it also did not reflect significant variations. The third patient experienced a very good response to the ECT sessions (Hamilton score 45 to 10) and also an improvement regarding the neurological symptoms. This patient presented a reduced perfusion in the medium-posterior parietal regions in the brain SPECT performed before the treatment; these regions presented a moderate improvement in the brain SPECT performed after the treatment. The patient who presented a significant neurological and psychiatric improvement also presented an improvement in the perfusion of the decreased areas in the brain SPECT and showed fewer alterations in the baseline brain SPECT compared with the others. The brain SPECT could have a prognostic (and confirmation) role regarding clinical improvement induced by ECT in resistant depression in Parkinson's disease. ECT is an alternative in treatment of severe depressive drug-resistant episodes associated to the Parkinson's disease.
我们研究了三名患有帕金森病的女性(分别为66岁、72岁和72岁),她们的病程分别为11年、6年和21年,均出现了耐药性严重抑郁发作,并接受了电休克治疗(ECT)。我们在ECT治疗前后进行了脑单光子发射计算机断层扫描(SPECT,使用99mTc-HMPAO)。使用汉密尔顿评分来衡量严重抑郁发作的临床改善情况。第一名患者没有出现任何临床改善(汉密尔顿评分从42降至42)。该患者治疗前的脑SPECT显示顶叶后部区域、前扣带回皮质以及额叶内侧和顶叶皮质灌注减少。治疗后,脑SPECT没有出现显著变化。第二名患者有中度临床改善(汉密尔顿评分从46降至36),神经症状也有中度改善。治疗前的脑SPECT显示左侧颞叶皮质和顶叶中后区域灌注减少。治疗后,也没有显示出显著变化。第三名患者对ECT治疗反应良好(汉密尔顿评分从45降至10),神经症状也有所改善。该患者治疗前的脑SPECT显示顶叶中后区域灌注减少;治疗后的脑SPECT显示这些区域有中度改善。在神经和精神方面有显著改善的患者,其脑SPECT中灌注减少区域也有改善,并且与其他患者相比,基线脑SPECT中的改变更少。脑SPECT对于帕金森病耐药性抑郁症患者ECT诱导的临床改善可能具有预后(和确认)作用。ECT是治疗与帕金森病相关的严重耐药性抑郁发作的一种选择。