Weinreb Linda, Wehler Cheryl, Perloff Jennifer, Scott Richard, Hosmer David, Sagor Linda, Gundersen Craig
Department of Family Medicine and Community Health. Pediatrics, University of Massachusetts Medical School, Worcester, Massachusetts 01655, USA.
Pediatrics. 2002 Oct;110(4):e41. doi: 10.1542/peds.110.4.e41.
Hunger, with its adverse consequences for children, continues to be an important national problem. Previous studies that document the deleterious effects of hunger among children cannot distinguish child from family hunger and do not take into account some critical environmental, maternal, and child variables that may influence child outcomes. This study examines the independent contribution of child hunger on children's physical and mental health and academic functioning, when controlling for a range of environmental, maternal, and child factors that have also been associated with poor outcomes among children.
With the use of standardized tools, comprehensive demographic, psychosocial, and health data were collected in Worcester, Massachusetts, from homeless and low-income housed mothers and their children (180 preschool-aged children and 228 school-aged children). Mothers and children were part of a larger unmatched case-control study of homelessness among female-headed households. Hunger was measured by a set of 7 dichotomous items, each asking the mother whether she has or her children have experienced a particular aspect of hunger during the past year--1 concerns food insecurity for the entire family, 2 concern adult hunger, and 4 involve child hunger. The items, taken from the Childhood Hunger Identification Project measure, are summed to classify the family and divided into 3 categories: no hunger, adult or moderate child hunger, or severe child hunger (indicating multiple signs of child hunger). Outcome measures included children's chronic health condition count using questions adapted from the National Health Interview Survey, Child Health Supplement, and internalizing behavior problems and anxiety/depression, measured by the Child Behavior Checklist. Additional covariates included demographic variables (ie, age, gender, ethnicity, housing status, number of moves, family size, income), low birth weight, child life events (ie, care and protection order, out of home placement, abuse, severe life events count), developmental problems (ie, developmental delay, learning disability, emotional problems), and mother's distress and psychiatric illness. Multivariate regression analyses examined the effect of child hunger on physical and mental health outcomes.
The average family size for both preschoolers and school-aged children was 3; about one third of both groups were white and 40% Puerto Rican. The average income of families was approximately $11 000. Among the school-aged children, on average 10 years old, 50% experienced moderate child hunger and 16% severe child hunger. Compared with those with no hunger, school-aged children with severe hunger were more likely to be homeless (56% vs 29%), have low birth weights (23% vs 6%), and have more stressful life events (9 vs 6) when compared with those with no hunger. School-aged children with severe hunger scores had parent-reported anxiety scores that were more than double the scores for children with no hunger and significantly higher chronic illness counts (3.4 vs 1.8) and internalizing behavior problems when compared with children with no hunger. There was no relationship between hunger and academic achievement. Among preschool-aged children, who averaged 4 years of age, 51% experienced moderate child hunger and 8% severe child hunger. For preschoolers, compared with children with no hunger, severe hunger was associated with homelessness (75% vs 48%), more traumatic life events (8.5 vs 6), low birth weight (23% vs 6%), and higher levels of chronic illness and internalizing behavior problems. Mothers of both preschoolers and school-aged children who reported severe hunger were more likely to have a lifetime diagnosis of posttraumatic stress disorder. For school-aged children, severe hunger was a significant predictor of chronic illness after controlling for housing status, mother's distress, low birth weight, and child live events. For preschoolers, moderate hunger was a significant predictor of health conditions while controlling for potenns while controlling for potential explanatory factors. For both preschoolers and school-aged children, severe child hunger was associated with higher levels of internalizing behavior problems. After controlling for housing status, mother's distress, and stressful life events, severe child hunger was also associated with higher reported anxiety/depression among school-aged children.
This study goes beyond previous research and highlights the independent relationship between severe child hunger and adverse physical health and mental health outcomes among low-income children. Study findings underscore the importance of clinical recognition of child hunger and its outcomes, allowing for preventive interventions and efforts to increase access to food-related resources for families.
饥饿及其对儿童的不良影响仍是一个重要的全国性问题。以往记录儿童饥饿有害影响的研究无法区分儿童饥饿与家庭饥饿,也未考虑一些可能影响儿童结局的关键环境、母亲和儿童变量。本研究在控制一系列也与儿童不良结局相关的环境、母亲和儿童因素的情况下,考察儿童饥饿对儿童身心健康和学业表现的独立影响。
在马萨诸塞州伍斯特市,使用标准化工具收集了无家可归和低收入家庭母亲及其子女(180名学龄前儿童和228名学龄儿童)的综合人口统计学、心理社会和健康数据。母亲和孩子是一项关于女性户主家庭无家可归问题的规模更大的非匹配病例对照研究的一部分。饥饿通过一组7个二分项目进行测量,每个项目询问母亲她或她的孩子在过去一年中是否经历过饥饿的某个特定方面——1个涉及整个家庭的粮食不安全,2个涉及成人饥饿,4个涉及儿童饥饿。这些项目取自儿童饥饿识别项目测量法,将其相加后对家庭进行分类,并分为3类:无饥饿、成人或中度儿童饥饿、或重度儿童饥饿(表明存在多种儿童饥饿迹象)。结局指标包括使用改编自《国家健康访谈调查》儿童健康补充部分的问题统计儿童的慢性健康状况,以及通过儿童行为清单测量内化行为问题和焦虑/抑郁。其他协变量包括人口统计学变量(即年龄、性别、种族、住房状况、搬家次数、家庭规模、收入)、低出生体重、儿童生活事件(即照料和保护令、离家安置、虐待、严重生活事件计数)、发育问题(即发育迟缓、学习障碍、情绪问题)以及母亲的痛苦和精神疾病。多变量回归分析考察了儿童饥饿对身心健康结局的影响。
学龄前儿童和学龄儿童的平均家庭规模均为3人;两组中约三分之一为白人,40%为波多黎各裔。家庭平均收入约为11000美元。在平均年龄为10岁的学龄儿童中,50%经历过中度儿童饥饿,16%经历过重度儿童饥饿。与无饥饿的儿童相比,重度饥饿的学龄儿童更有可能无家可归(56%对29%)、低出生体重(23%对6%),并且与无饥饿的儿童相比有更多压力大的生活事件(9次对6次)。重度饥饿得分的学龄儿童父母报告的焦虑得分是无饥饿儿童得分的两倍多,与无饥饿儿童相比,慢性病计数显著更高(3.4对1.8),内化行为问题也更多。饥饿与学业成绩之间没有关系。在平均年龄为4岁的学龄前儿童中,51%经历过中度儿童饥饿,8%经历过重度儿童饥饿。对于学龄前儿童,与无饥饿的儿童相比,重度饥饿与无家可归(75%对48%)、更多创伤性生活事件(8.5次对6次)、低出生体重(23%对6%)以及更高水平的慢性病和内化行为问题相关。报告有重度饥饿的学龄前儿童和学龄儿童的母亲更有可能被诊断为终生患有创伤后应激障碍。对于学龄儿童,在控制住房状况、母亲的痛苦、低出生体重和儿童生活事件后,重度饥饿是慢性病的一个重要预测因素。对于学龄前儿童,在控制潜在解释因素时,中度饥饿是健康状况的一个重要预测因素。对于学龄前儿童和学龄儿童,重度儿童饥饿都与更高水平的内化行为问题相关。在控制住房状况、母亲的痛苦和压力大的生活事件后,重度儿童饥饿也与学龄儿童报告的更高的焦虑/抑郁相关。
本研究超越了以往的研究,突出了重度儿童饥饿与低收入儿童不良身体健康和心理健康结局之间的独立关系。研究结果强调了临床识别儿童饥饿及其结局的重要性,以便进行预防性干预,并努力为家庭增加获取与食物相关资源的机会。