Nevill Alan M, Brown Damon, Godfrey Richard, Johnson Patrick, Romer Lee, Stewart Arthur D, Winter Edward M
School of Sport, Performing Arts and Leisure, University of Wolverhampton, Walsall, United Kingdom.
Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2003 Mar;35(3):488-94. doi: 10.1249/01.MSS.0000053728.12929.5D.
To compare the maximum oxygen uptake V0(2max) of elite endurance athletes and to explain why the body mass exponent, necessary to render V0(2max) independent of body mass, appears to be greater than 0.67.
Study 1: V0(2max) of 174 international sportsmen and women was assessed. Athletes were recruited from seven sports (middle- and long-distance runners, heavyweight and lightweight rowers, triathletes, and squash and badminton players). Study 2: calf and thigh leg muscle masses were estimated in 106 male and 30 female athletes from 11 sports. Differences in V0(2max) and leg muscle masses between "sports" and "sex" were analyzed independent of body mass by using allometric log-linear ANCOVA.
Heavyweight rowers had the greatest V0(2max) when expressed in L.min but long-distance runners had the highest V0(2max)in mL.kg.min. However, the ANCOVA identified no difference in "mass independent" V0(2max) between the five "pure" endurance sports (runners, rowers, and triathletes) (P > 0.05) with the two racket sports being significantly lower. The body mass covariate exponent was inflated, estimated as 0.94. The results from study 2 estimated calf and thigh leg muscle masses to increase in proportion to body mass, and, respectively.
After having controlled for differences in body mass, V0(2max) did not differ between pure endurance sports (P > 0.05). Assuming that athletes' thigh muscle mass increases in proportion to body mass as observed in study 2, a similar disproportional increase in V0(2max) would be anticipated, providing a plausible explanation for the inflated mass exponent associated with V0(2max) identified in this and other studies.
比较优秀耐力运动员的最大摄氧量(V0₂max),并解释为何使V0₂max与体重无关所需的体重指数似乎大于0.67。
研究1:评估了174名国际男女运动员的V0₂max。运动员来自七个运动项目(中长跑运动员、重量级和轻量级赛艇运动员、铁人三项运动员以及壁球和羽毛球运动员)。研究2:估计了来自11个运动项目的106名男性和30名女性运动员的小腿和大腿肌肉质量。通过使用异速生长对数线性协方差分析,独立于体重分析了“运动项目”和“性别”之间V0₂max和腿部肌肉质量的差异。
以L.min表示时,重量级赛艇运动员的V0₂max最大,但以mL.kg.min表示时,长跑运动员的V0₂max最高。然而,协方差分析表明,五个“纯”耐力运动项目(跑步运动员、赛艇运动员和铁人三项运动员)之间的“与体重无关的”V0₂max没有差异(P>0.05),而两个球拍类运动项目的该值显著较低。体重协变量指数被夸大,估计为0.94。研究2的结果估计小腿和大腿肌肉质量分别与体重成比例增加。
在控制了体重差异后,纯耐力运动项目之间的V0₂max没有差异(P>0.05)。假设如研究2中所观察到的,运动员的大腿肌肉质量与体重成比例增加,那么预计V0₂max也会有类似的不成比例增加,这为本次研究及其他研究中所确定的与V0₂max相关的夸大的体重指数提供了一个合理的解释。