Cartier Carolyn
Department of Geography, University of Southern California, 3620 S Vermont Avenue, Los Angeles, CA 90089, USA.
Soc Sci Med. 2003 Jun;56(11):2289-301. doi: 10.1016/s0277-9536(02)00228-9.
Economic restructuring in the health services industry in the USA exemplifies general patterns of economic change propelled by neoliberalism, especially industry privatization, diminished social services, and dependence on "flexible" labor and management regimes. Combined with the widespread entry of women into the labor force, an aging population, and minimal assistance for high quality long-term care at the end of life, these economic and social conditions raise a set of difficult policy questions for health services planning. Set in these broad contexts, this paper situates access to and experience of health services in the home, the hospital, and nursing facility, to demonstrate how economic changes have relocated and redefined health services in ways that distinctively impact how people experience the places where they receive care. This place switching of health services externalizes costs of subacute and "daily life care" (the so-called custodial care) to the sphere of the individual, their family, and communities. The theoretical analysis uses current geographical and philosophical approaches to place and space, and considers the tensions between institutionally managed health care space, and the patient's experience of receiving health services in place. The place/space dilemma of health services provision is examined through several interrelated subjects: long-term care at the end of life, gendered characteristics of care giving, the limitations of Medicare and Medicaid, historical changes in hospital length of stay, the restructuring of nursing practices, and the "no-care zone". The analysis is based on examples of stroke and incontinence care to demonstrate the importance of considering place and space issues in health care planning.
美国医疗服务行业的经济结构调整体现了新自由主义推动的经济变革的一般模式,特别是行业私有化、社会服务减少以及对“灵活”劳动力和管理制度的依赖。再加上女性广泛进入劳动力市场、人口老龄化以及临终时高质量长期护理的援助极少,这些经济和社会状况给医疗服务规划带来了一系列棘手的政策问题。在这些广泛背景下,本文探讨了在家庭、医院和护理机构中获得医疗服务的情况以及体验,以说明经济变化如何重新定位和重新定义医疗服务,从而显著影响人们在接受护理场所的体验方式。医疗服务的这种场所转换将亚急性和“日常生活护理”(即所谓的监护护理)的成本外部化到个人、其家庭和社区领域。理论分析采用当前关于场所和空间的地理及哲学方法,并考虑机构管理的医疗保健空间与患者在场所接受医疗服务体验之间的紧张关系。通过几个相互关联的主题来审视医疗服务提供中的场所/空间困境:临终时的长期护理、护理的性别特征、医疗保险和医疗补助的局限性、住院时间的历史变化、护理实践的重组以及“无护理区”。分析基于中风和失禁护理的例子,以证明在医疗保健规划中考虑场所和空间问题的重要性。