Ogura Akio, Miyai Akira, Maeda Fumie, Fukutake Hiroyuki, Kikumoto Rikiya
Department of Radiology, Kyoto City Hospital.
Nihon Hoshasen Gijutsu Gakkai Zasshi. 2003 Apr;59(4):508-13. doi: 10.6009/jjrt.kj00003174111.
The signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of a magnetic resonance image is a common measure of imager performance. However, evaluations for the calculation of the SNR use various methods. A problem with measuring SNR is caused by the distortion of noise statistics in commonly used magnitude images. In this study, measurement accuracy was compared among four methods of evaluating SNR according to the size and position of regions of interest (ROIs). The results indicated that the method that used the difference between two images showed the best agreement with the theoretical value. In the method that used a single image, the SNR calculated by using a small size of ROI showed better agreement with the theoretical value because of noise bias and image artifacts. However, in the method that used the difference between two images, a large size of ROI was better in reducing statistical errors. In the same way, the methods that used air noise and air signal were better when applied to a large ROI. In addition, the image subtraction process used to calculate pixel-by-pixel differences in images may reach zero on a minus pixel value when using an image processor with the MRI system and apparatuses associated with it. A revised equation is presented for this case. It is important to understand the characteristics of each method and to choose a suitable method carefully according to the purpose of the study.
磁共振图像的信噪比(SNR)是成像器性能的常用度量指标。然而,用于计算SNR的评估采用了各种方法。测量SNR的一个问题是由常用幅度图像中噪声统计的失真引起的。在本研究中,根据感兴趣区域(ROI)的大小和位置,比较了四种评估SNR方法的测量准确性。结果表明,使用两幅图像之间差值的方法与理论值的一致性最佳。在使用单幅图像的方法中,由于噪声偏差和图像伪影,使用小尺寸ROI计算的SNR与理论值的一致性更好。然而,在使用两幅图像之间差值的方法中,大尺寸ROI在减少统计误差方面更好。同样,使用空气噪声和空气信号的方法应用于大ROI时效果更好。此外,在使用与MRI系统及其相关设备的图像处理器计算图像中逐像素差值的图像减法过程中,当使用负像素值时可能会达到零。针对这种情况给出了一个修正方程。了解每种方法的特点并根据研究目的仔细选择合适的方法很重要。