Horstmann Gernot
Department of Psychology, University of Bielefeld, Germany.
Emotion. 2003 Jun;3(2):150-66. doi: 10.1037/1528-3542.3.2.150.
Emotion theorists assume certain facial displays to convey information about the expresser's emotional state. In contrast, behavioral ecologists assume them to indicate behavioral intentions or action requests. To test these contrasting positions, over 2,000 online participants were presented with facial expressions and asked what they revealed-feeling states, behavioral intentions, or action requests. The majority of the observers chose feeling states as the message of facial expressions of disgust, fear, sadness, happiness, and surprise, supporting the emotions view. Only the anger display tended to elicit more choices of behavioral intention or action request, partially supporting the behavioral ecology view. The results support the view that facial expressions communicate emotions, with emotions being multicomponential phenomena that comprise feelings, intentions, and wishes.
情感理论家认为某些面部表情能够传达表达者的情绪状态信息。相比之下,行为生态学家则认为这些表情表明行为意图或行动请求。为了检验这些截然不同的观点,研究人员向2000多名在线参与者展示面部表情,并询问他们这些表情所揭示的内容——情绪状态、行为意图还是行动请求。大多数观察者选择情绪状态作为厌恶、恐惧、悲伤、快乐和惊讶等面部表情所传达的信息,这支持了情感观点。只有愤怒表情往往引发更多关于行为意图或行动请求的选择,这部分支持了行为生态学观点。研究结果支持了面部表情传达情绪的观点,即情绪是一种多成分现象,包括感受、意图和愿望。