Bleich Avraham, Gelkopf Marc, Solomon Zahava
Lev-Hasharon Mental Health Center, Tel-Aviv University Sackler School of Medicine, Tel-Aviv, Israel.
JAMA. 2003 Aug 6;290(5):612-20. doi: 10.1001/jama.290.5.612.
The terrorist attacks on Israeli society have been ongoing since September 2000. However, few studies have examined the impact of terrorism on nationally representative population samples, and no study has examined the psychological impact of ongoing terrorism in Israel.
To determine the level of exposure to terrorist attacks and the prevalence of traumatic stress-related (TSR) symptoms, symptoms of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and sense of safety after 19 months of terrorism in Israel, and to identify correlates of the psychological sequelae and the modes of coping with the terrorism.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: Telephone survey conducted April-May 2002, using a strata sampling method, of 902 eligible households and a representative sample of 742 Israeli residents older than 18 years (82% contact rate) and a final participation of 512 (57%).
Number of TSR symptoms, rates of those with symptom criteria for PTSD and acute stress disorder assessed by the Stanford Acute Stress Reaction Questionnaire, self-reported feelings of depression, optimism, sense of safety, help-seeking, and modes of coping.
Of 512 survey participants, 84 (16.4%) had been directly exposed to a terrorist attack and 191 (37.3%) had a family member or friend who had been exposed. Of 510 participants who responded to questions about TSR symptoms, 391 (76.7%) had at least 1 TSR symptom (mean, 4.0 [SD, 4.5]; range, 0-23; mean intensity, 0.8; range, 0-4). Symptom criteria for PTSD were met by 48 participants (9.4%) and criteria for acute stress disorder, by 1 participant; 299 (58.6%) reported feeling depressed. The majority of respondents expressed optimism about their personal future (421/512 [82.2%]) and the future of Israel (307/509 [66.8%]), and expressed self-efficacy with regard to their ability to function in a terrorist attack (322/431 [74.6%]). Most expressed a low sense of safety with respect to themselves (307/509 [60.4%]) and their relatives (345/507 [67.9%]). Few reported a need for professional help (27/506 [5.3%]). Female sex, sense of safety, and use of tranquilizers, alcohol, and cigarettes to cope were associated with TSR symptoms and symptom criteria for PTSD; level of exposure and objective risk were not. The most prevalent coping mechanisms were active information search about loved ones and social support.
Considering the nature and length of the Israeli traumatic experience, the psychological impact may be considered moderate. Although the survey participants showed distress and lowered sense of safety, they did not develop high levels of psychiatric distress, which may be related to a habituation process and to coping mechanisms.
自2000年9月以来,针对以色列社会的恐怖袭击一直在持续。然而,很少有研究调查恐怖主义对具有全国代表性的人口样本的影响,并且没有研究调查以色列持续的恐怖主义造成的心理影响。
确定在以色列经历19个月的恐怖主义活动后,遭受恐怖袭击的程度、创伤应激相关(TSR)症状的患病率、创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)症状以及安全感,并确定心理后遗症的相关因素和应对恐怖主义的方式。
设计、背景和参与者:2002年4月至5月进行的电话调查,采用分层抽样方法,对902户符合条件的家庭进行调查,抽取了742名18岁以上以色列居民的代表性样本(联系率82%),最终有512人(57%)参与。
TSR症状的数量、根据斯坦福急性应激反应问卷评估的符合PTSD和急性应激障碍症状标准的比例、自我报告的抑郁情绪、乐观情绪、安全感、寻求帮助情况以及应对方式。
在512名调查参与者中,84人(16.4%)曾直接遭受恐怖袭击,191人(37.3%)有家庭成员或朋友曾遭受袭击。在510名回答TSR症状相关问题的参与者中,391人(76.7%)至少有1种TSR症状(平均4.0[标准差4.5];范围0 - 23;平均强度0.8;范围0 - 4)。48名参与者(9.4%)符合PTSD症状标准,1名参与者符合急性应激障碍标准;299人(58.6%)报告有抑郁情绪。大多数受访者对自己的个人未来(421/512[82.2%])和以色列的未来(307/509[66.8%])表示乐观,并对自己在恐怖袭击中的应对能力表示有自我效能感(322/431[74.6%])。大多数人对自己(307/509[60.4%])和亲属(345/507[67.9%])表示安全感较低。很少有人报告需要专业帮助(27/506[5.3%])。女性、安全感以及使用镇静剂、酒精和香烟来应对与TSR症状和PTSD症状标准相关;遭受袭击程度和客观风险则无关。最常见的应对机制是积极寻找有关亲人的信息和社会支持。
考虑到以色列创伤经历的性质和持续时间,心理影响可能被认为是中度的。尽管调查参与者表现出痛苦和安全感降低,但他们并未出现高水平的精神痛苦,这可能与适应过程和应对机制有关。