Ekholm Ola
National Institute of Public Health, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Eur J Clin Nutr. 2004 Jan;58(1):60-3. doi: 10.1038/sj.ejcn.1601746.
To estimate the accuracy of recall on self-reported alcohol intake.
Population-based random sample.
The Danish Health and Morbidity Survey 1994.
The study is based on 6,354 persons chosen at random among the adult Danish citizens. The response rate was 77%.
Number of alcoholic drinks consumed on each day during the last week.
For self-reported alcohol intake on the last Saturday, respondents with a recall period of one day have the shortest recall period (reference group) and respondents with a recall period of seven days the longest. Respondents with a recall period of seven days reported significant lower alcohol intake (Odds Ratio: 0.56). The reported alcohol intake declines when the recall period increases. The decline in recall of alcohol intake is very clear already after 2-3 days.
The systematic decrease in reported alcohol use with increased recall period indicates problems in correctly reporting alcohol intake for a full week. Many surveys use recall periods that are longer than a week and, therefore, underreported alcohol intake is expected to be even higher.
评估自我报告饮酒量的回忆准确性。
基于人群的随机样本。
1994年丹麦健康与发病率调查。
该研究基于从成年丹麦公民中随机选取的6354人。应答率为77%。
上周每天饮用的酒精饮料数量。
对于上周六自我报告的饮酒量,回忆期为一天的应答者回忆期最短(参照组),回忆期为七天的应答者回忆期最长。回忆期为七天的应答者报告的饮酒量显著较低(优势比:0.56)。随着回忆期延长,报告的饮酒量下降。饮酒量回忆的下降在2至3天后就已非常明显。
随着回忆期延长,报告的饮酒量系统性减少,这表明在准确报告一整周的饮酒量方面存在问题。许多调查使用的回忆期超过一周,因此,预计饮酒量报告不足的情况会更高。