Levin O S, Khutorskaia O E, Amosova N A, Smolentseva I G, Shtok V N
Zh Nevrol Psikhiatr Im S S Korsakova. 2003;103(11):4-9.
Because differential diagnosis between Parkinson's disease (PD) and multiple system atrophy (MSA) may be difficult due to overlapping of clinical features, especially at the early stage of the diseases, a search for additional clinical and instrumental markers increasing reliability of etiological diagnosis appears actual. The article presents the results of comprehensive comparison of parkinsonian signs and spectral electromyography (sEMG) data in 18 patients with MSA, diagnosed clinically according to criteria of Gilman et al (1998), and in 21 PD patients. Though no between-group differences in total expression of parkinsonian signs evaluated with The Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale, part III, were found, MSA patients demonstrated progressive motor deficits, severer hypokinesia in the distal regions of the extremities, more pronounced impairment of axial movements, postural instability and gait disturbances but milder resting tremor, as compared to the PD patients (p < 0.05). Besides, the MSA patients were more frequently resistant to levodopa and had axial drug-induced dyskinesia (p < 0.05). An analysis of sEMG data revealed that MSA patients had a more prominent peak in 10-17 Hz frequency band (for arm muscles) and in Hz 7-14 (for leg muscles) as well as higher amplitudes peak frequencies (p < 0.05) positively correlated to hypokinesia severity. The results may be useful for differential diagnosis between PD and MSA.
由于帕金森病(PD)和多系统萎缩(MSA)的临床特征存在重叠,尤其是在疾病早期,二者的鉴别诊断可能存在困难,因此寻找能够提高病因诊断可靠性的额外临床和仪器标记显得很有必要。本文介绍了18例根据吉尔曼等人(1998年)标准临床诊断为MSA的患者以及21例PD患者的帕金森氏征和频谱肌电图(sEMG)数据的综合比较结果。尽管使用统一帕金森病评定量表第三部分评估的帕金森氏征总表达在两组之间未发现差异,但与PD患者相比,MSA患者表现出进行性运动功能障碍、四肢远端更严重的运动迟缓、轴性运动障碍更明显、姿势不稳和步态障碍,但静息震颤较轻(p < 0.05)。此外,MSA患者对左旋多巴的耐药性更高,且有轴性药物性运动障碍(p < 0.05)。对sEMG数据的分析表明,MSA患者在10 - 17Hz频段(手臂肌肉)和7 - 14Hz频段(腿部肌肉)有更突出的峰值,以及更高的振幅峰值频率(p < 0.05),且与运动迟缓严重程度呈正相关。这些结果可能有助于PD和MSA的鉴别诊断。