Clark P A, Bass D M, Looman W J, McCarthy C A, Eckert S
Margaret Blenkner Research Institute, Benjamin Rose, Cleveland, Ohio 44114, USA.
Aging Ment Health. 2004 Jan;8(1):40-51. doi: 10.1080/13607860310001613329.
This investigation evaluates effects of care consultation delivered within a partnership between a managed health care system and Alzheimer's Association chapter. Care consultation is a multi-component telephone intervention in which Association staff work with patients and caregivers to identify personal strengths and resources within the family, health plan, and community. The primary hypothesis is that care consultation will decrease utilization of managed care services and improve psychosocial outcomes. A secondary modifying-effects hypothesis posits benefits will be greater for patients with more severe memory impairment. The sample is composed of managed care patients whose medical records indicate a diagnosis of dementia or memory loss. Patients were randomly assigned to an intervention group, which was offered care consultation in addition to usual managed care services, or to a control group, which was offered only usual managed care services. Data come from two in-person interviews with patients, and medical and administrative records. Results supporting the primary hypothesis show intervention group patients feel less embarrassed and isolated because of their memory problems and report less difficulty coping. Findings consistent with the modifying-effects hypothesis show intervention group patients with more severe impairment have fewer physician visits, are less likely to have an emergency department visit or hospital admission, are more satisfied with managed care services, and have decreased depression and strain.
本调查评估了在管理式医疗保健系统与阿尔茨海默病协会分会的合作关系中提供的护理咨询的效果。护理咨询是一种多方面的电话干预措施,协会工作人员与患者及其护理人员合作,以确定家庭、健康计划和社区内的个人优势和资源。主要假设是护理咨询将减少管理式医疗服务的使用并改善心理社会结果。一个次要的调节效应假设认为,对于记忆障碍更严重的患者,益处会更大。样本由管理式医疗患者组成,其病历显示患有痴呆症或记忆力丧失。患者被随机分配到干预组,除了接受常规管理式医疗服务外,还接受护理咨询,或者分配到对照组,只接受常规管理式医疗服务。数据来自对患者的两次面对面访谈以及医疗和行政记录。支持主要假设的结果表明,干预组患者因记忆问题而感到尴尬和孤立的程度较低,并且报告应对困难较少。与调节效应假设一致的研究结果表明,损伤更严重的干预组患者看医生的次数较少,急诊就诊或住院的可能性较小,对管理式医疗服务更满意,并且抑郁和压力有所减轻。