Croisile B, Astier J-L, Beaumont C
Laboratoire de Neuropsychologie, Fonctions cognitives, Langage et Mémoire, Hôpital Neurologique, Lyon.
Rev Neurol (Paris). 2003 Nov;159(11):1009-15.
It may be difficult to distinguish between a primary progressive aphasia at a very mild stage from the beginning of Alzheimer's disease (AD). However, this may be achieved by carrying out simple neuro-psychological tests. Nine non-fluent PPA (NFPPA) and 76 AD patients with comparable MMSE as well as 58 control subjects were evaluated using simple tests: MMSE, fluency, apraxia, naming, digital span, story memory, 5 words memory test. NFPPA patients had significantly impaired functions during the semantic category fluency and naming tests as compared to AD patients, whereas they showed a better delayed recall of the 5 words and story memory tests. As compared to AD, MMSE of NFPPA patients was also better in the time orientation and word recall sub-tests, although inferior in words repetition and language items. Thus, with comparable MMSE, NFPPA patients have more lexico-semantic difficulties, but a better delayed verbal memory than AD patients. These simple tests easily confirm the language impairment of NFPPA patients as opposed to the mnestic difficulties of AD, even at very early stages of these pathologies.
在疾病初期,很难区分非常轻微阶段的原发性进行性失语症与阿尔茨海默病(AD)。然而,这可以通过进行简单的神经心理学测试来实现。使用简单测试对9名非流利性原发性进行性失语症(NFPPA)患者、76名具有可比简易精神状态检查表(MMSE)的AD患者以及58名对照受试者进行了评估:MMSE、语言流畅性、失用症、命名、数字广度、故事记忆、5个单词记忆测试。与AD患者相比,NFPPA患者在语义类别流畅性和命名测试中的功能明显受损,而在5个单词和故事记忆测试的延迟回忆方面表现更好。与AD相比,NFPPA患者在时间定向和单词回忆子测试中的MMSE也更好,尽管在单词重复和语言项目方面较差。因此,在MMSE相当的情况下,NFPPA患者存在更多词汇语义困难,但延迟言语记忆比AD患者更好。这些简单测试很容易证实NFPPA患者的语言障碍,而非AD患者的记忆困难,即使在这些疾病的非常早期阶段也是如此。