Rafeek Reisha N, Marchan Shivaughn M, Naidu Rahul S, Carrotte Peter V
School of Dentistry, Faculty of Medical Sciences, University of the West Indies, Mount Hope, Trinidad & Tobago.
J Dent Educ. 2004 Jan;68(1):81-8.
The aims of this study were to describe levels of self-rated competency of dental graduates from the University of the West Indies (UWI) and to investigate relationships with gender and the effect of curriculum change. A thirty-two item self-reported postal questionnaire was sent to UWI dental alumni (1994-2002). The questionnaire included twenty-eight competencies that could be rated on a 5-point scale: 1 (not at all competent) to 5 (very competent). Overall preparedness for practice could also be rated from 1 (not at all prepared) to 5 (very prepared). The response rate was 77.4 percent, with a mean age of 29.3 years. Items with the highest mean scores were taking an adequate medical history (4.49), recognizing and treating dental caries (4.46), oral examination (4.36), and giving dental health education (4.35). Those with the lowest rating were designing and undertaking clinical research (2.29), dealing with practice management issues (2.52), designing and delivering crown and bridge work (3.33), and recognizing pathologic occlusions (3.33). Overall preparedness for practice was rated as 3.27. Female graduates rated four competencies significantly higher than males. Graduates exposed to the new curriculum perceived greater overall preparedness for general dental practice, suggesting the change to a competency-based curriculum was effective.
本研究的目的是描述西印度群岛大学(UWI)牙科学毕业生的自我评定能力水平,并调查其与性别的关系以及课程改革的影响。一份包含32个条目的自填式邮政问卷被寄给了UWI的牙科校友(1994 - 2002年毕业)。问卷包括28项能力,这些能力可按5分制进行评分:1分(完全没有能力)至5分(非常有能力)。实践的总体准备情况也可从1分(完全没有准备)至5分(非常有准备)进行评分。回复率为77.4%,平均年龄为29.3岁。平均得分最高的项目是获取充分的病史(4.49)、识别和治疗龋齿(4.46)、口腔检查(4.36)以及提供口腔健康教育(4.35)。得分最低的是设计和开展临床研究(2.29)、处理实践管理问题(2.52)、设计和实施冠桥修复(3.33)以及识别病理性咬合(3.33)。实践的总体准备情况评分为3.27。女性毕业生对四项能力的评分显著高于男性。接触新课程的毕业生认为自己对一般牙科实践的总体准备更充分,这表明向基于能力的课程转变是有效的。