Mumford Rick, Skelton Anna, Metcalfe Emily, Walsh Kathy, Boonham Neil
Central Science Laboratory, PHL 2 (Virology), Sand Hutton, York YO41 1LZ, UK.
J Virol Methods. 2004 May;117(2):153-9. doi: 10.1016/j.jviromet.2004.01.006.
Barley yellow mosaic virus (BaYMV) and Barley mild mosaic virus (BaMMV) are economically-important, soil-borne pathogens of winter barley. Until recently, laboratory diagnosis of these pathogens has relied upon ELISA using polyclonal antiserum. However, due to the unstable nature of these viruses, combined with the inability to sap transmit BaYMV, high quality antiserum has been difficult to obtain and as a result the performance of ELISA is often unsatisfactory. As an alternative approach two TaqMan assays (one BaYMV-specific and the other BaMMV-specific) have been developed. These assays have been validated for three seasons, by testing samples in parallel with ELISA. This testing indicates that TaqMan is a more reliable detection method than ELISA, especially with late-season and mixed infection samples. Data is also provided on a comparison of using simplex assays versus a multiplex assay for detecting BaYMV and BaMMV. The results indicate that while multiplexing does lead to a small reduction in sensitivity, it can be used reliably to streamline routine diagnosis. Further improvements in the development of a routine diagnostic procedure are also described including details of a rapid automated extraction procedure (Kingfisher) and the use of a novel cereal-specific control assay.
大麦黄花叶病毒(BaYMV)和大麦轻花叶病毒(BaMMV)是对经济有重要影响的冬大麦土传病原体。直到最近,这些病原体的实验室诊断一直依赖于使用多克隆抗血清的酶联免疫吸附测定(ELISA)。然而,由于这些病毒的不稳定性,再加上无法通过汁液传播BaYMV,高质量的抗血清很难获得,因此ELISA的性能往往不尽人意。作为一种替代方法,已经开发了两种TaqMan检测方法(一种针对BaYMV,另一种针对BaMMV)。通过与ELISA平行检测样品,这些检测方法已经在三个季节中得到验证。该检测表明,TaqMan是一种比ELISA更可靠的检测方法,特别是对于季末和混合感染的样品。还提供了关于使用单重检测法与多重检测法检测BaYMV和BaMMV的比较数据。结果表明,虽然多重检测确实会导致灵敏度略有降低,但它可以可靠地用于简化常规诊断。文中还描述了常规诊断程序开发中的进一步改进,包括快速自动提取程序(翠鸟)的细节以及一种新型谷物特异性对照检测法的使用。