Irita Kazuo, Kawashima Yasuo, Iwao Yasuhide, Seo Norimasa, Tsuzaki Koichi, Morita Kiyoshi, Obara Hidefumi
Department of Anesthesiology and Critical Care Medicine, Graduate School of Medical Sciences, Kyushu University, Fukuoka 812-8582.
Masui. 2004 Mar;53(3):320-35.
The Japanese Society of Anesthesiologists (JSA) conducts an annual survey of life-threatening events in operating rooms (OR) in JSA Certified Training Hospitals (JSACTH) by sending and collecting confidential questionnaires. Etiologies of the incidents were divided into four categories: those totally attributable to anesthetic management (AM), those resulting from preoperative complications (PC), those resulting from intraoperative pathological events (IP) and those related to surgical procedures (SP). IP resulted from coronary ischemia not suspected preoperatively, arrhythmias, pulmonary embolism, and other conditions. Outcomes were judged on the 7th post-operative day. In the year 2002, questionnaires were sent to 844 JSACTHs, and a total of 1,461,020 cases of anesthesia were documented from 773 JSACTHs. Of these, 1,277,045 cases of anesthesia from 712 JSACTHs were available for analysis. Seven hundred thirty nine cardiac arrests (5.79 per 10,000 anesthetics) and 806 deaths (6.31 per 10,000 anesthetics) due to life-threatening events in the OR were reported. The incidence of cardiac arrest and mortality totally attributable to AM was 0.38 and 0.11 per 10,000 anesthetics. These values tended to decrease after 1994, except the mortality totally attributable to AM, which were almost at constant level during recent years. The summary of the study between 1999 and 2002 was as follows. Among 3,855,384 anesthetics, 2,443 cardiac arrests (6.34 per 10,000 anesthetics) and 2,638 deaths (6.85 per 10,000 anesthetics) due to life-threatening events in the OR were reported. PC, SP, IP and AM were responsible for 64.7, 23.9, 9.4, and 1.5% of deaths, respectively. The major cause of PC related deaths was preoperative hemorrhagic shock, followed by cardiovascular diseases such as myocardial ischemia and congestive heart failure. Excessive surgical bleeding comprised 70.2% of SP-related deaths. The major causes of IP-related death were myocardial ischemia, pulmonary embolism, and severe arrhythmias. The incidence of cardiac arrest and death totally attributable to AM was 0.47 and 0.10/10,000 anesthetics, respectively. Among patients with ASA-PS 1(E) and 2(E), AM-related deaths occurred at a rate of 0.04/10,000 anesthetics. Half of AM-induced deaths were caused by airway or ventilatory problems. Other causes of AM-related death were medication accidents and infusion/transfusion accidents. Considerable effort is required to reduce intraoperative life-threatening events caused by human error, hemorrhage, and cardiovascular diseases.
日本麻醉医师协会(JSA)通过发放和收集保密问卷,对JSA认证培训医院(JSACTH)手术室(OR)中的危及生命事件进行年度调查。事件的病因分为四类:完全归因于麻醉管理(AM)的事件、术前并发症(PC)导致的事件、术中病理事件(IP)导致的事件以及与手术操作(SP)相关的事件。IP由术前未怀疑的冠状动脉缺血、心律失常、肺栓塞和其他情况引起。在术后第7天判断结果。2002年,向844家JSACTH发放了问卷,773家JSACTH共记录了1,461,020例麻醉病例。其中,712家JSACTH的1,277,045例麻醉病例可供分析。报告了739例心脏骤停(每10,000例麻醉中有5.79例)和806例因手术室危及生命事件导致的死亡(每10,000例麻醉中有6.31例)。完全归因于AM的心脏骤停和死亡率分别为每10,000例麻醉中有0.38例和0.11例。1994年后这些值呈下降趋势,但完全归因于AM的死亡率近年来几乎保持在恒定水平。1999年至2002年的研究总结如下。在3,855,384例麻醉中,报告了2,443例心脏骤停(每10,000例麻醉中有6.34例)和2,638例因手术室危及生命事件导致的死亡(每10,000例麻醉中有6.85例)。PC、SP、IP和AM分别导致64.7%、23.9%、9.4%和1.5%的死亡。与PC相关死亡的主要原因是术前出血性休克,其次是心血管疾病,如心肌缺血和充血性心力衰竭。与SP相关死亡中,手术出血过多占70.2%。与IP相关死亡的主要原因是心肌缺血、肺栓塞和严重心律失常。完全归因于AM的心脏骤停和死亡率分别为每10,000例麻醉中有0.47例和0.10例。在ASA-PS 1(E)和2(E)的患者中,与AM相关的死亡发生率为每10,000例麻醉中有0.04例。AM导致的死亡中有一半是由气道或通气问题引起的。与AM相关死亡的其他原因是用药事故和输液/输血事故。需要付出巨大努力来减少由人为失误、出血和心血管疾病导致的术中危及生命事件。