Rasmussen Susanne R, Prescott Eva, Sørensen Thorkild I A, Søgaard Jes
DSI Danish Institute for Health Services Research, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Eur J Public Health. 2004 Mar;14(1):95-100. doi: 10.1093/eurpub/14.1.95.
Net costs of smoking in a lifetime perspective and, hence, the economic interests in antismoking policies have been questioned. It has been proposed that the health-related costs of smoking are balanced by smaller expenditure due to shorter life expectancy.
A dynamic (life cycle) method taking differences in life expectancy into account. Main outcome measures were direct and indirect lifetime health costs for ever-smokers and never-smokers, and cost ratios (ever-smokers to never-smokers). The estimations were based on annual disease rates of use of the healthcare services, smoking relative risks, smoking prevalences, and costs.
Annual direct and indirect costs of ever-smokers were higher than for never-smokers in all age groups of both genders. The direct and indirect cost ratios were highest at age 45 for women, and at age 35 and 40 for men, respectively. Taking life expectancy differences into account, direct and indirect lifetime health costs for men aged 35, discounted by 5% per year were 66% and 83% higher in ever-smokers than in never-smokers. Corresponding results for women were 74% and 79%, respectively. The results are insensitive to a broad range of relative risk-estimates and discount rates including no discounting. Excess costs of ever-smokers disappear if the inclusion of smoking-related diseases is narrowed to that of previous studies.
Smoking imposes costs to society even when taking life expectancy into consideration--both in direct and indirect costs.
从终身角度来看吸烟的净成本,以及因此在反吸烟政策中的经济利益受到了质疑。有人提出,吸烟相关的健康成本因预期寿命缩短导致的支出减少而得到平衡。
一种考虑预期寿命差异的动态(生命周期)方法。主要结局指标是曾经吸烟者和从不吸烟者的直接和间接终身健康成本,以及成本比率(曾经吸烟者与从不吸烟者之比)。估计基于医疗服务使用的年度疾病发生率、吸烟相对风险、吸烟流行率和成本。
在所有年龄组和两性中,曾经吸烟者的年度直接和间接成本均高于从不吸烟者。女性的直接和间接成本比率在45岁时最高,男性分别在35岁和40岁时最高。考虑到预期寿命差异,35岁男性的直接和间接终身健康成本,按每年5%贴现后,曾经吸烟者比从不吸烟者分别高出66%和83%。女性的相应结果分别为74%和79%。结果对包括不贴现在内的广泛相对风险估计和贴现率不敏感。如果将与吸烟相关疾病的纳入范围缩小到先前研究的范围,曾经吸烟者的额外成本就会消失。
即使考虑到预期寿命,吸烟也会给社会带来成本——包括直接成本和间接成本。