Chanpattana Worrawat, Kramer Barry Alan
Department of Psychiatry, Bangkok Hospital, Thailand.
J ECT. 2004 Jun;20(2):94-8. doi: 10.1097/00124509-200406000-00004.
To obtain an overview of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) practice in Thailand.
Questionnaires were sent to all institutions providing psychiatric care; data were collected from September 1, 2001, to August 31, 2002.
Fifty-three responses were received from 67 institutions (79.1%). ECT is available in 26 hospitals. Approximately 6,914 patients received 51,565 ECT treatments, of which, 6,469 patients (93.56%) received 48,240 treatments (93.55%) in the psychiatric hospitals. The ECT utilization rate was 11.15 patients treated per 100,000. Twelve institutions used MECTA (Spectrum or SR1) or Thymatron DGx. Bilateral ECT was used exclusively in all institutions. In 2 medical schools, all patients received double ECT throughout their treatment courses. Unmodified ECT was always used in nine psychiatric hospitals and five general hospitals, and occasionally used in 2 university hospitals comprising 94.2% of all ECT usage. Patients with schizophrenia most frequently received ECT (74%), followed by mania (8%) and major depression (7%). The nurse alone administered ECT in four psychiatric hospitals. Although the death rate was estimated at 0.08%, there was no ECT-related death during the survey period. Continuation ECT was performed in 11 and maintenance ECT in 6 institutions. Five institutions had acceptable training programs for psychiatry residents but none had training syllabus, 2 institutions had teaching schedule for medical students.
ECT use in Thailand is high. Nearly all ECTs (93.6%) were performed in the psychiatric hospital and 94.2% of all treatments were unmodified ECT. Lacking of proper training in ECT is evident.
了解泰国电休克治疗(ECT)的应用概况。
向所有提供精神科护理的机构发放问卷;收集2001年9月1日至2002年8月31日的数据。
67家机构中有53家回复(79.1%)。26家医院可提供ECT。约6914例患者接受了51565次ECT治疗,其中6469例患者(93.56%)在精神病医院接受了48240次治疗(93.55%)。ECT利用率为每10万人中有11.15例接受治疗。12家机构使用MECTA(Spectrum或SR1)或Thymatron DGx。所有机构均仅采用双侧ECT。在2所医学院,所有患者在整个治疗过程中均接受双次ECT。9家精神病医院和5家综合医院一直使用未改良的ECT,2所大学医院偶尔使用,占所有ECT使用量的94.2%。精神分裂症患者接受ECT治疗最为频繁(74%),其次是躁狂症(8%)和重度抑郁症(7%)。4家精神病医院仅由护士实施ECT。尽管估计死亡率为0.08%,但调查期间无与ECT相关的死亡病例。11家机构进行维持性ECT,6家机构进行巩固性ECT。5家机构为精神科住院医师提供了可接受的培训项目,但均无培训大纲,2家机构为医学生制定了教学计划。
泰国ECT的使用率较高。几乎所有的ECT(93.6%)在精神病医院进行,所有治疗中有94.2%是未改良的ECT。ECT缺乏适当培训的情况很明显。