Manimaran N, Galland R B
Department of Surgery, Royal Berkshire Hospital, Reading, UK.
Ann R Coll Surg Engl. 2004 Jul;86(4):292-5. doi: 10.1308/147870804218.
Routine digital rectal examination (DRE) in children with abdominal pain has slowly gone out of practice but is still performed routinely in adults. This study was undertaken to assess the significance of routine DRE in adults with acute abdominal pain.
A total of 100 consecutive adults admitted to the emergency surgical unit with acute abdominal pain were studied prospectively. Following DRE, patients who were willing to participate in the study were requested to complete an anonymous questionnaire. The house officer conducted the rectal examination at admission and also completed an evaluation sheet.
A working diagnosis of acute appendicitis in 38 patients and gastroduodenal, pancreatobiliary pathology in 24 patients was made. DRE did not alter clinical diagnosis or initial management in any of the 100 patients. Routine DRE did not detect any unrelated pathology. Of the patients, 93 wanted to know why rectal examination was required. Overall, 78 patients rated the DRE as uncomfortable. Although 43 were willing for DRE as a routine, 54 patients preferred to have the DRE at the time of other bowel tests rather than at the time of the emergency admission.
Various routine medical procedures have given way to evidence-based practice. This study has demonstrated the limited role of routine DRE in adults with no anorectal or GI symptoms during their initial evaluation for acute abdominal pain.
对腹痛儿童进行常规直肠指检(DRE)的做法已逐渐不再使用,但在成人中仍常规进行。本研究旨在评估常规DRE在成人急性腹痛中的意义。
前瞻性研究了连续100例因急性腹痛入住急诊外科病房的成人患者。直肠指检后,要求愿意参与研究的患者填写一份匿名问卷。住院医师在患者入院时进行直肠检查,并填写一份评估表。
38例患者确诊为急性阑尾炎,24例患者确诊为胃十二指肠、胰腺胆道病变。直肠指检未改变100例患者中的任何一例的临床诊断或初始治疗。常规直肠指检未发现任何无关病变。93例患者想知道为何需要进行直肠检查。总体而言,78例患者认为直肠指检不舒服。虽然43例患者愿意将直肠指检作为常规检查,但54例患者更倾向于在进行其他肠道检查时而非急诊入院时进行直肠指检。
各种常规医疗程序已让位于循证医学实践。本研究表明,在对无肛肠或胃肠道症状的成人急性腹痛进行初始评估时,常规直肠指检的作用有限。