Huang Xinjiang, Pedersen Theresa, Fischer Michael, White Richard, Young Thomas M
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of California-Davis, One Shields Avenue, Davis, California 95616, USA.
Environ Sci Technol. 2004 Jun 15;38(12):3272-8. doi: 10.1021/es034848+.
Controversy remains about the importance of nonlinear sorption isotherms, desorption rate limitations, and aging effects, collectively referred to as nonideal sorption processes, in controlling the fate and transport of organic contaminants. Herbicide runoff from highway soils represents a good test case for assessing the relative importance of nonideal sorption because runoff flow rates are often high, soil-water contacttimes are short, and significant time is available for contaminant aging after application. This study examines the sorption and desorption of five herbicides with a wide range of properties (isoxaben, oryzalin, diuron, clopyralid, and glyphosate) on soil samples from two roadsides in northern California and uses the results to examine field runoff data from multiple rainy seasons. Nonideal sorption processes do not appear to be significant in determining herbicide runoff at the field sites because (i) sorption isotherms were linear or slightly nonlinear for all compounds but glyphosate, (ii) field runoff concentration ratios between isoxaben and oryzalin were consistent with linear partitioning predictions, (iii) runoff leaving the site appeared to be in equilibrium with local soil concentrations, and (iv) desorption distribution coefficients for aged herbicides on soil samples collected from the field site did not differ substantially from those obtained in short-term laboratory adsorption experiments. Collectively, these findings indicate that linear equilibrium models are adequate for predicting the concentration of herbicides in runoff in these field settings and that more complicated nonideal models do not need to be invoked. Vegetated slopes effectively reduced the herbicide loads, with average removals of 35-80% occurring as runoff traversed a 3-m segment 1 m from the edge of the spray zone.
关于非线性吸附等温线、解吸速率限制和老化效应(统称为非理想吸附过程)在控制有机污染物的归宿和迁移方面的重要性,仍存在争议。公路土壤中的除草剂径流是评估非理想吸附相对重要性的一个很好的测试案例,因为径流流速通常很高,土壤与水的接触时间很短,而且在施用后有大量时间让污染物老化。本研究考察了五种性质差异较大的除草剂(异恶草酮、仲丁灵、敌草隆、氯吡嘧磺隆和草甘膦)在加利福尼亚北部两条路边土壤样品上的吸附和解吸情况,并利用结果检验了多个雨季的田间径流数据。在这些田间地点,非理想吸附过程在决定除草剂径流方面似乎并不显著,原因如下:(i)除草甘膦外,所有化合物的吸附等温线均为线性或略微非线性;(ii)异恶草酮和仲丁灵之间的田间径流浓度比与线性分配预测结果一致;(iii)离开该地点的径流似乎与当地土壤浓度处于平衡状态;(iv)从田间地点采集的土壤样品上老化除草剂的解吸分配系数与短期实验室吸附实验得到的结果没有显著差异。总体而言,这些发现表明,线性平衡模型足以预测这些田间环境中径流中除草剂的浓度,无需采用更复杂的非理想模型。植被坡有效地降低了除草剂负荷,径流穿过距喷洒区边缘1米处的3米路段时,平均去除率为35%-80%。