Sharaf Ravi N, Weinshel Elizabeth H, Bini Edmund J, Rosenberg Jonathan, Sherman Alex, Ren Christine J
Division of Gastroenterology and Department of Surgery, New York University School of Medicine, New York, NY, USA.
Obes Surg. 2004 Nov-Dec;14(10):1367-72. doi: 10.1381/0960892042583806.
The role of upper endoscopy (EGD) in obese patients prior to bariatric surgery is controversial. The aim of this study was to evaluate the diagnostic yield and cost of routine EGD before bariatric surgery.
The medical records of consecutive obese patients who underwent EGD prior to bariatric surgery between May 2000 and September 2002 were reviewed. Two experienced endoscopists reviewed all EGD reports, and findings were divided into 4 groups based on predetermined criteria: group 0 (normal study), group 1 (abnormal findings that neither changed the surgical approach nor postponed surgery), group 2 (abnormal findings that changed the surgical approach or postponed surgery), and group 3 (results that were an absolute contraindication to surgery). Clinically important findings included lesions in groups 2 and 3. The cost of EGD (430.72 US dollars) was estimated using the endoscopist fee under Medicare reimbursement.
During the 28-month study period, 195 patients were evaluated by EGD prior to bariatric surgery. One or more lesions were identified in 89.7% of patients, with 61.5% having a clinically important finding. The prevalence of endoscopic findings using the classification system above was as follows: group 0 (10.3%), group 1 (28.2%), group 2 (61.5%), and group 3 (0.0%). Overall, the most common lesions identified were hiatal hernia (40.0%), gastritis (28.7%), esophagitis (9.2%), gastric ulcer (3.6%), Barrett's esophagus (3.1%), and esophageal ulcer (3.1%). The cost of performing routine endoscopy on all patients prior to bariatric surgery was 699.92 US dollars per clinically important lesion detected.
Routine upper endoscopy before bariatric surgery has a high diagnostic yield and has a low cost per clinically important lesion detected.
在减重手术前,上消化道内镜检查(EGD)在肥胖患者中的作用存在争议。本研究的目的是评估减重手术前常规EGD的诊断率及成本。
回顾了2000年5月至2002年9月期间在减重手术前行EGD检查的连续肥胖患者的病历。两名经验丰富的内镜医师查阅了所有EGD报告,并根据预定标准将检查结果分为4组:0组(检查正常)、1组(异常发现但既未改变手术方式也未推迟手术)、2组(异常发现改变了手术方式或推迟了手术)和3组(结果为手术绝对禁忌证)。具有临床重要意义的发现包括2组和3组中的病变。EGD的成本(430.72美元)根据医疗保险报销规定的内镜医师费用进行估算。
在28个月的研究期间,195例患者在减重手术前行EGD检查。89.7%的患者发现一处或多处病变,其中61.5%有具有临床重要意义的发现。使用上述分类系统的内镜检查结果患病率如下:0组(10.3%)、1组(28.2%)、2组(61.5%)和3组(0.0%)。总体而言,最常见的病变为食管裂孔疝(40.0%)、胃炎(28.7%)、食管炎(9.2%)、胃溃疡(3.6%)、巴雷特食管(3.1%)和食管溃疡(3.1%)。对所有患者在减重手术前进行常规内镜检查,每发现一处具有临床重要意义的病变,成本为699.92美元。
减重手术前常规上消化道内镜检查具有较高的诊断率,且每发现一处具有临床重要意义的病变成本较低。