Goto Junichi, Kataoka Ryoichi, Hirayama Noriaki
Computational Science Department, Ryoka Systems Inc., 1-5-2 Irifune, Urayasu, Chiba 279-0012, Japan.
J Med Chem. 2004 Dec 30;47(27):6804-11. doi: 10.1021/jm0493818.
The development and validation of the program Ph4Dock is presented. Ph4Dock is a novel automated ligand docking program that makes best use of pharmacophoric features both in a ligand and at concave portions of a protein. By mapping of pharmacophores of the ligand to the pharmacophoric features that represent the concaves of the target protein, Ph4Dock realizes an efficient and accurate prediction of the binding modes between the ligand and the protein. To validate the potential of this unique docking algorithm, we have selected 43 reliable crystal structures of protein-ligand complexes. All of the ligands are druglike, and they are varied in nature. The diffraction-component precision index (DPI) originally used in crystallography was applied in this study in order to evaluate the docking results quantitatively. The root-mean-square deviation (rmsd) between non-hydrogen atoms of the ligand in the prediction and experimental results were analyzed using DPI. The rmsd values for 25 structures, consisting of almost 60% of the dataset, are less than three times of the corresponding DPI values. It means that the precision of docking results obtained by Ph4Dock is mostly equivalent to the experimental error in these cases. The present study has demonstrated that Ph4Dock can accurately reproduce the experimentally determined docking modes if the reliable crystal structures are used. Normally the success rate of the docking is judged using rmsd < or = 2.0 A as the criterion. The Ph4Dock marked an appreciably good success rate of 86% based on this criterion.
本文介绍了Ph4Dock程序的开发与验证。Ph4Dock是一款新型的自动配体对接程序,它能充分利用配体和蛋白质凹面部分的药效团特征。通过将配体的药效团映射到代表靶蛋白凹面的药效团特征上,Ph4Dock实现了对配体与蛋白质结合模式的高效准确预测。为了验证这种独特对接算法的潜力,我们选择了43个可靠的蛋白质-配体复合物晶体结构。所有配体均类药,且性质各异。本研究采用了晶体学中最初使用的衍射分量精度指数(DPI)来定量评估对接结果。使用DPI分析预测结果与实验结果中配体非氢原子之间的均方根偏差(rmsd)。25个结构的rmsd值(占数据集近60%)小于相应DPI值的三倍。这意味着在这些情况下,Ph4Dock获得的对接结果精度大多与实验误差相当。本研究表明,如果使用可靠的晶体结构,Ph4Dock可以准确重现实验确定的对接模式。通常对接成功率的判断标准是rmsd≤2.Å。基于此标准,Ph4Dock的成功率高达86%,相当可观。