Lotz J-P, Bui B, Gomez F, Théodore C, Caty A, Fizazi K, Gravis G, Delva R, Peny J, Viens P, Duclos B, De Revel T, Curé H, Gligorov J, Guillemaut S, Ségura C, Provent S, Droz J-P, Culine S, Biron P
Department of Medical Oncology, Hôpital Tenon, Paris, France.
Ann Oncol. 2005 Mar;16(3):411-8. doi: 10.1093/annonc/mdi087. Epub 2005 Jan 19.
High-dose chemotherapy (HD-CT) is able to circumvent platinum resistance of resistant/refractory germ-cell tumors (GCTs), but expectancy of cure remains low. New strategies are needed with new drugs and a sequential approach.
Patients with relapsed poor-prognosis GCTs were scheduled to receive two cycles combining epirubicin and paclitaxel (Taxol) followed by three consecutive HD-CT supported by stem cell transplantation [one course combining cyclophosphamide, 3 g/m(2) + thiotepa, 400 mg/m(2), followed by two ICE regimens (ifosfamide, 10 g/m(2), carboplatin, AUC 20, etoposide, 1500 mg/m(2))].
From March 1998 to September 2001 (median follow-up, 31.8 months), 45 patients (median age, 28 years) were enrolled in this phase II study. Twenty-two patients received the complete course. Twenty-five patients died from progression and five from toxicity. The overall response rate was 37.7%, including an 8.9% complete response rate. The median overall survival was 11.8 months. The 3-year survival and progression-free survival rate was 23.5%. The 'Beyer' prognostic score predicted the outcome after HD-CT.
Although our results warrant further studies on HD-CT in relapsed poor prognosis GCTs, patients with a Beyer score >2 did not benefit from this approach and should not be enrolled in HD-CT trials. Better selection criteria have to be fulfilled in forthcoming studies.
大剂量化疗(HD-CT)能够克服耐药/难治性生殖细胞肿瘤(GCT)的铂耐药性,但治愈的期望仍然很低。需要采用新药和序贯方法的新策略。
复发的预后不良GCT患者计划接受两个周期的表柔比星和紫杉醇(泰素)联合治疗,随后进行三个连续的由干细胞移植支持的大剂量化疗疗程[一个疗程为环磷酰胺3 g/m² + 噻替派400 mg/m²联合,随后是两个ICE方案(异环磷酰胺10 g/m²、卡铂曲线下面积20、依托泊苷1500 mg/m²)]。
从1998年3月至2001年9月(中位随访时间31.8个月),45例患者(中位年龄28岁)纳入了这项II期研究。22例患者接受了完整疗程。25例患者死于疾病进展,5例死于毒性反应。总缓解率为37.7%,其中完全缓解率为8.9%。中位总生存期为11.8个月。3年生存率和无进展生存率为23.5%。“拜尔”预后评分可预测大剂量化疗后的结果。
尽管我们的结果值得对复发的预后不良GCT患者进行大剂量化疗的进一步研究,但拜尔评分>2的患者未从此方法中获益,不应纳入大剂量化疗试验。在未来的研究中必须满足更好的选择标准。