Klapach A S, Callaghan J J, Miller K A, Goetz D D, Sullivan P M, Pedersen D R, Johnston R C
Iowa Methodist Medical Center, Des Moines, Iowa, USA.
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2005 Feb;87(2):280-5. doi: 10.2106/JBJS.D.02130.
We previously evaluated a cohort of fifty-three patients with severe hip dysplasia (Crowe Type-II, III, or IV subluxation) who underwent a total of sixty-six Charnley total hip arthroplasties. The acetabular component was placed at the anatomic hip center, the superolateral defect was filled with cement, and no bone-grafting was used to supplement the acetabular wall. All but one patient, who was lost to follow-up, were followed until death or for a minimum of twenty years. Radiographic and functional follow-up data were collected prospectively. This retrospective review included twenty-four patients (thirty-four hips) who were alive at a minimum of twenty years following the surgery. Fourteen (22%) of the sixty-five hips underwent revision of a component, with eleven of the revisions performed because of aseptic loosening. Eight of those eleven hips underwent revision because of acetabular loosening alone; two, because of femoral loosening alone; and one, because of loosening of both components. The combined prevalence of revision because of aseptic loosening of the acetabular component and radiographic evidence of failure of the acetabular component was 28% (eighteen hips). With the numbers available, the need for acetabular revision was not associated with the percentage of cement coverage (p = 0.362) or the Crowe classification (p = 0.159). At a minimum of twenty years postoperatively, the survivorship of the acetabular component was 86% +/- 8% with revision because of aseptic loosening as the end point and 82% +/- 10% with revision because of aseptic loosening or radiographic evidence of loosening as the end point. The results that we evaluated at a minimum of twenty years after use of this technique can be compared with the results of other techniques in studies with similar long-term follow-up periods.
我们之前评估了一组53例严重髋关节发育不良(Crowe II型、III型或IV型半脱位)患者,他们总共接受了66次Charnley全髋关节置换术。髋臼假体放置在髋关节解剖中心,髋臼上外侧缺损用骨水泥填充,未使用植骨来补充髋臼壁。除1例失访患者外,所有患者均随访至死亡或至少20年。前瞻性收集了影像学和功能随访数据。这项回顾性研究纳入了24例患者(34髋),他们在手术后至少存活20年。65髋中有14髋(22%)进行了假体翻修,其中11次翻修是由于无菌性松动。这11髋中,8髋仅因髋臼松动进行翻修;2髋仅因股骨松动进行翻修;1髋因两个组件均松动进行翻修。因髋臼组件无菌性松动而翻修以及髋臼组件出现影像学松动失败的综合发生率为28%(18髋)。就现有数据而言,髋臼翻修的必要性与骨水泥覆盖百分比(p = 0.362)或Crowe分级(p = 0.159)无关。术后至少20年时,以无菌性松动导致的翻修为终点,髋臼组件的生存率为86%±8%;以无菌性松动或影像学松动为终点,生存率为82%±10%。我们在使用该技术至少20年后评估的结果可与其他技术在类似长期随访研究中的结果进行比较。