Kalisińska Elzbieta
Department of Zoology, Agricultural University in Szczecin, Doktora Judyma 20, 71-466 Szczecin, Poland.
Brain Behav Evol. 2005;65(4):244-61. doi: 10.1159/000084315. Epub 2005 Mar 8.
The size of the brain and its macro-anatomical parts in 206 birds representing 19 anseriform species and 4 tribes (Anserini, Anatini, Aythyini and Mergini) was the subject of a comparative analysis. The comparisons involved two aspects: taxonomic (differences among species within tribes and differences among tribes) and ecological (diet composition: vegetation, invertebrates, or fish and the foraging mode: browsing, dabbling, shallow diving, and deep diving). The relative size of the encephalon (E) and its parts (optic tectum, OT; cerebellum, C; brain stem, BS; hemispheres, H) were described using appropriate indices. Five of them, called the cerebral-body indices (E/BW, OT/BW, C/BW, BS/BW, H/BW), involved a ratio between the weight of E or its parts and that of the body (BW). Four intracerebral indices (OT/E, C/E, BS/E, H/E) and allometric equations were used as well. Almost all the indices showed a high intraspecific variability within the Anserini and Mergini; on the other hand, the intracerebral indices did not differ between the species of the Anatini and Aythyini (except for OT/E in the Aythyini). Between-tribe differences were reflected in all 9 indices. The birds feeding on different diets were found to differ in their OT/E and H/E. The herbivorous anserifom OT/E was clearly lower than that of those birds feeding on invertebrates and fish. The highest OT/E was that of the piscivorous birds. In terms of foraging mode, significant differences were revealed in 7 out of the 9 indices used (differences in OT/BW and C/BW proved non-significant). OT/E of the browsing birds was clearly lower than that of the deep diving ducks; BS/E of the browsers was much lower than that of the dabbling and shallow diving ducks. Geese and swans (browsers) showed much higher H/E compared to the deep diving sea ducks. The latter revealed the highest C/E, but significant differences were detected only in comparison with C/E of the shallow diving ducks. The taxonomic (among tribes) and ecological comparisons showed more differences in the intracerebral indices than in the cerebral-body indices.
对代表19种雁形目物种和4个族(雁族、鸭族、潜鸭族和海鸭族)的206只鸟类的大脑及其宏观解剖部分的大小进行了比较分析。比较涉及两个方面:分类学(族内物种间的差异以及族间的差异)和生态学(饮食组成:植被、无脊椎动物或鱼类以及觅食方式:啃食、浅尝、浅潜和深潜)。使用适当的指数描述了脑(E)及其各部分(视叶,OT;小脑,C;脑干,BS;大脑半球,H)的相对大小。其中五个指数,称为脑体指数(E/BW、OT/BW、C/BW、BS/BW、H/BW),涉及E或其各部分的重量与身体重量(BW)之间的比率。还使用了四个脑内指数(OT/E、C/E、BS/E、H/E)和异速生长方程。几乎所有指数在雁族和海鸭族内都表现出较高的种内变异性;另一方面,鸭族和潜鸭族的物种之间脑内指数没有差异(潜鸭族的OT/E除外)。族间差异在所有9个指数中都有体现。发现以不同食物为食的鸟类在OT/E和H/E方面存在差异。食草雁形目的OT/E明显低于以无脊椎动物和鱼类为食的鸟类。OT/E最高的是食鱼鸟类。在觅食方式方面,在所使用的9个指数中有7个显示出显著差异(OT/BW和C/BW的差异被证明不显著)。啃食鸟类的OT/E明显低于深潜鸭;啃食鸟类的BS/E远低于浅尝和浅潜鸭。与深潜海鸭相比,鹅和天鹅(啃食者)的H/E要高得多。后者的C/E最高,但仅与浅潜鸭的C/E相比检测到显著差异。分类学(族间)和生态学比较表明,脑内指数的差异比脑体指数的差异更多。