Mel'nik B S, Garbuzinskiĭ S A, Lobanov M Iu, Galzitskaia O V
Mol Biol (Mosk). 2005 Jan-Feb;39(1):129-38.
We have analyzed the proteins whose structures were determined both by X-ray analysis (X-ray) and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) on condition that these structures do not differ greatly when spatially superimposed on each other (61 pairs of protein structures). Atom-atomic contacts (contact distances varied from 2 to 8 A) have been analyzed and it has been found that NMR structures (in comparison with X-ray ones) have more contacts in the range below 3.5 A and above 5.5 A. In the case of residue-residue contacts NMR structures have more contacts below 3 A and between 4.5 and 6.5 A. At all the other contact distances analyzed the X-ray structures have more contacts. The difference in the number of atom-atomic and residue-residue contacts is greater for internal residues, that are concealed from water, as compared to the surface residues. The other, not less important difference deals with the number of hydrogen bonds in the main chain: it is larger for the X-ray structures. The correlation between the hydrogen bonds identified in the structures obtained by both methods is no more than 32%. The consideration of a complete set of protein structures obtained by NMR results in the fact that the number of hydrogen bonds grows 1.2 times as compared to those obtained with the X-ray analysis, whereas the correlation increases only by 65%. We have also demonstrated that alpha-helices in the NMR structures are more distorted in comparison with the ideal alpha-helix, than alpha-helices in the X-ray structures.
我们分析了那些其结构已通过X射线分析(X射线)和核磁共振(NMR)确定的蛋白质,条件是这些结构在空间上相互叠加时差异不大(61对蛋白质结构)。已对原子-原子接触(接触距离在2至8埃之间变化)进行了分析,结果发现,与X射线结构相比,NMR结构在3.5埃以下和5.5埃以上范围内有更多接触。就残基-残基接触而言,NMR结构在3埃以下以及4.5至6.5埃之间有更多接触。在分析的所有其他接触距离下,X射线结构有更多接触。与表面残基相比,对于那些被水遮蔽的内部残基,原子-原子和残基-残基接触数量的差异更大。另一个同样重要的差异涉及主链中氢键的数量:X射线结构中的氢键数量更多。两种方法获得的结构中所识别的氢键之间的相关性不超过32%。考虑通过NMR获得的完整蛋白质结构集,结果是氢键数量与通过X射线分析获得的相比增长了1.2倍,而相关性仅增加了65%。我们还证明,与X射线结构中的α螺旋相比,NMR结构中的α螺旋与理想α螺旋相比扭曲程度更大。