Farooq M A, Devitt A T
Department of Orthopaedics, Our Lady's Hospital, Navan, Co. Meath.
Ir J Med Sci. 2005 Jan-Mar;174(1):26-32. doi: 10.1007/BF03168515.
Efficacy of intra-articular injections is controversial and published studies on efficacy and risks are few.
We sought the opinion of practicing orthopaedic consultants in order to establish the perceived benefits and risks of infection following intra-articular steroids.
A questionnaire was sent to all the orthopaedic consultants in the UK and Ireland on the use of intra-articular steroids.
A total of 853 completed questionnaires (response rate 57.4%) were analysed. The perceived risk of infection was 1:1000 in almost half of the surgeons polled and 1:10,000 in one third. The 759 consultants who administer intra-articular steroids recalled sixty-eight cases of infection; 85.2 % of the surgeons rated efficacy 5 or above on a visual analog score of 1-10.
Correct patient selection, proper indications for use, and a limited number of appropriately spaced injections were all perceived to be important to achieve maximum benefit without serious side-effects.
关节内注射的疗效存在争议,且关于其疗效和风险的已发表研究较少。
我们征求了骨科执业顾问的意见,以确定关节内注射类固醇后感染的潜在益处和风险。
向英国和爱尔兰的所有骨科顾问发送了一份关于关节内类固醇使用情况的问卷。
共分析了853份完整问卷(回复率57.4%)。几乎一半接受调查的外科医生认为感染风险为1:1000,三分之一的医生认为是1:10000。759位进行关节内类固醇注射的顾问回忆起68例感染病例;85.2%的外科医生在1-10的视觉模拟评分中将疗效评为5分或以上。
正确的患者选择、适当的使用指征以及有限次数且间隔适当的注射,都被认为对于在无严重副作用的情况下实现最大益处至关重要。