Schlacher Thomas A, Liddell Ben, Gaston Troy F, Schlacher-Hoenlinger Monika
Faculty of Science, University of the Sunshine Coast, Maroochydore, QLD, 4558, Australia.
Oecologia. 2005 Aug;144(4):570-84. doi: 10.1007/s00442-005-0041-4. Epub 2005 May 11.
Excess nitrogen is a forceful agent of ecological change in coastal waters, and wastewater is a prominent source of nitrogen. In catchments where multiple sources of nitrogen pollution co-exist, biological indicators are needed to gauge the degree to which wastewater-N can propagate through the receiving food webs. The purpose of this study was to test whether estuarine fish are suitable as indicators of sewage-N pollution. Fish were analysed from three estuaries within a 100-km strip on the Australian East Coast. The estuaries differ substantially in wastewater loading: (1) the Maroochy Estuary receives a large fraction of the local shire's treated sewage, (2) the Mooloolah Estuary has no licensed treated wastewater outfalls but marinas/harbours and storm-water may contribute nitrogen, and (3) the Noosa Estuary which neither receives licensed discharges nor has suspected wastewater loads. Sampling for fish included both high rainfall ('wet' season) and low rainfall ('dry' season) periods. Muscle-delta15N was the variable predicted to respond to treated wastewater loading, reflecting the relative enrichment in 15N resulting from the treatment process and distinguishing it from alternative N sources such as fertiliser and natural nitrogen inputs (both 15N-depleted). Of the 19 fish species occurring in all three estuaries, those from the Maroochy Estuary had significantly elevated delta15N values (up to 9.9 per thousand), and inter-estuarine differences in fish-delta15N were consistent across seasons. Furthermore, not only did all fish from the estuary receiving treated wastewater carry a very distinctive sewage-N tissue signal, but enriched muscle-delta15N was also evident in all species sampled from the one estuary in which sewage contamination was previously only suspected (i.e. the Mooloolah Estuary: 0.2-4.8 per thousand enrichment over fish from reference system). Thus, fish-delta15N is a suitable indicator of wastewater-N not only in systems that receive large loads, but also for the detection of more subtle nitrogen inputs. Arguably, fish may be preferred indicators of sewage-N contamination because they: (1) integrate nitrogen inputs over long time periods, (2) have an element of 'ecological relevance' because fish muscle-delta15N reflect movement of sewage-N through the food chain, and (3) pollution assessments can usually be based on evidence from multiple species.
过量的氮是沿海水域生态变化的一个有力因素,而废水是氮的一个主要来源。在存在多种氮污染源的集水区,需要生物指标来衡量废水氮通过受纳食物网传播的程度。本研究的目的是测试河口鱼类是否适合作为污水氮污染的指标。对澳大利亚东海岸100公里范围内的三个河口的鱼类进行了分析。这些河口的废水负荷差异很大:(1)马鲁奇河口接收当地郡处理后的大部分污水;(2)穆卢拉河口没有经许可的处理后废水排放口,但码头/港口和雨水可能会贡献氮;(3)努萨河口既不接收经许可的排放物,也没有可疑的废水负荷。鱼类采样包括高降雨量(“湿”季)和低降雨量(“干”季)时期。肌肉δ15N是预计会对处理后废水负荷作出反应的变量,反映了处理过程中15N的相对富集,并将其与化肥和天然氮输入等其他氮源(两者均为15N贫化)区分开来。在所有三个河口都出现的19种鱼类中,来自马鲁奇河口的鱼类的δ15N值显著升高(高达9.9‰),且鱼类δ15N的河口间差异在各季节均保持一致。此外,不仅来自接收处理后废水的河口的所有鱼类都带有非常独特的污水氮组织信号,而且在以前仅怀疑有污水污染的一个河口(即穆卢拉河口:比参考系统中的鱼类富集0.2 - 4.8‰)采样的所有物种中,肌肉δ15N富集也很明显。因此,鱼类δ15N不仅是接收大量负荷的系统中废水氮的合适指标,也是检测更细微氮输入的合适指标。可以说,鱼类可能是污水氮污染的首选指标,因为它们:(1)在长时间内整合氮输入;(2)具有“生态相关性”,因为鱼类肌肉δ15N反映了污水氮在食物链中的移动;(3)污染评估通常可以基于多种物种的证据。