Ehrensaft Miriam K
Division of Child Psychiatry, Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons, 1051 Riverside Drive, Unit 47, New York 10032, USA.
Clin Child Fam Psychol Rev. 2005 Mar;8(1):39-63. doi: 10.1007/s10567-005-2341-y.
This article investigates the role of interpersonal relationships in shaping sex differences in the manifestation, etiology, and developmental course of conduct problems and their treatment needs. The review examines whether: (1) Girls' conduct problems are more likely than boys' to manifest as a function of disrupted relationships with caretakers and peers; (2) For girls more than for boys, the outcomes of conduct problems in adolescence and adulthood, and related treatment needs, are more likely to be a consequence of the quality of interpersonal relationships with others, particularly opposite-sex peers and partners. Evidence reviewed suggests that boys and girls share many similarities in their expression of conduct problems, but that a relational perspective does unify important differences. There is fair evidence that girls with conduct problems are more likely to come to the attention of authorities because of chaotic, unstable family relationships, and to express antisocial behavior in the context of close relationships; there is stronger evidence that the course and outcomes of conduct problems in females versus males pertain to interpersonal relationship impairments. Those sex differences map onto specific differences in treatment needs. Further empirical testing of the proposed relational model is indicated.
本文探讨人际关系在塑造品行问题的表现、病因、发展过程及其治疗需求方面的性别差异中所起的作用。该综述考察了以下方面:(1)女孩的品行问题是否比男孩更有可能因与照顾者及同伴关系的破裂而表现出来;(2)相较于男孩,女孩在青少年期和成年期品行问题的后果以及相关治疗需求是否更有可能是与他人,尤其是异性同伴和伴侣人际关系质量的结果。所审查的证据表明,男孩和女孩在品行问题的表现上有许多相似之处,但从关系角度确实能统一一些重要差异。有充分证据表明,有品行问题的女孩因家庭关系混乱、不稳定而更有可能引起当局注意,并在亲密关系中表现出反社会行为;有更强的证据表明,女性与男性品行问题的过程和结果与人际关系受损有关。这些性别差异对应于治疗需求的具体差异。需要对所提出的关系模型进行进一步的实证检验。