Cherpitel Cheryl J, Ye Yu, Bond Jason, Borges Guilherme, Cremonte Mariana, Marais Sandra, Poznyak Vladimir, Sovinova Hana, Moskalewicz Jacek, Swiatkiewicz Grazyna
Alcohol Research Group, 2000 Hearst Avenue, Berkeley, California 94709, USA.
J Stud Alcohol. 2005 May;66(3):428-32. doi: 10.15288/jsa.2005.66.428.
There are little data available on the performance of brief screening instruments for alcohol-use disorders cross-nationally; therefore, we analyzed the performance of one such instrument in a number of countries.
Performance of the RAPS4 for tolerance and the RAPS4-QF for heavy drinking are analyzed from emergency room data across 13 countries included in the combined Emergency Room Collaborative Alcohol Analysis Project (ERCAAP) and the World Health Organization Collaborative Study on Alcohol and Injuries.
The RAPS4 showed good sensitivity and specificity for tolerance across most of the countries, but was higher in countries that were higher on societal-level detrimental drinking patterns. Prevalence of tolerance was also higher in those countries with high detrimental drinking pattern scores. Sensitivity of the RAPS4-QF for heavy drinking was uniformly high across countries, while maintaining good specificity, and did not vary by detrimental drinking patterns.
Findings suggest the RAPS4 and RAPS4-QF may hold promise cross-nationally. Future research should more fully address the performance of brief screening instruments for alcohol-use disorders (using standard diagnostic criteria) cross-nationally, with consideration of the impact of societal drinking patterns.
关于酒精使用障碍简短筛查工具在跨国应用中的表现,现有数据较少;因此,我们分析了其中一种工具在多个国家的表现。
通过综合急诊室酒精协作分析项目(ERCAAP)和世界卫生组织酒精与伤害协作研究中纳入的13个国家的急诊室数据,分析RAPS4量表用于耐受性评估的表现以及RAPS4-QF量表用于重度饮酒评估的表现。
在大多数国家,RAPS4量表对耐受性表现出良好的敏感性和特异性,但在社会层面有害饮酒模式较高的国家中该量表的得分更高。在有害饮酒模式得分高的国家中,耐受性的患病率也更高。RAPS4-QF量表对重度饮酒的敏感性在各国均普遍较高,同时保持良好的特异性,且不受有害饮酒模式的影响。
研究结果表明,RAPS4量表和RAPS4-QF量表在跨国应用中可能具有前景。未来的研究应更全面地探讨酒精使用障碍简短筛查工具(使用标准诊断标准)在跨国应用中的表现,并考虑社会饮酒模式的影响。