Tongtavee N, Shiowatana J, McLaren Ronald G, Gray Colin W
Department of Chemistry, Faculty of Science, Mahidol University, Bangkok, Thailand.
Sci Total Environ. 2005 Sep 15;348(1-3):244-56. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2004.12.066.
Isotope dilution methods using a stable isotope tracer ((207)Pb) were developed for the determination of Pb availability in contaminated soils. The methods included determination of E values (isotopically exchangeable pool), L values (plant labile pool) and isotopic exchange kinetics (IEK). Isotopically exchangeable Pb was monitored at different exchange times based on measurement of the (207)Pb/(208)Pb ratio in soil solution following addition of the tracer. The rate of decrease in the (207)Pb/(208)Pb ratio in solution could be described by using the same IEK equation as used previously with radioisotope tracers. The amounts of isotopically exchangeable Pb in Pb-contaminated soils estimated from long-term IEK parameters were in good agreement with directly determined E values up to 15 days. However, values of some of the fitted IEK parameters cast doubts on the validity of using the IEK approach with (207)Pb, most probably as a result of irreversible fixation of some of the spike by reactive surfaces in the soils. Estimation of isotopically exchangeable Pb using short-term kinetics data was unsuccessful, substantially underestimating E values. Results for the control (uncontaminated) soil were highly variable, most probably as a result of fixation of tracer by the soil and poor analytical precision due to low solution Pb concentrations. A compartmental analysis of the variation in E values with time indicates a good potential for estimating bioavailable Pb in contaminated soils. The amounts of available Pb obtained from summation of the E(1)(min) and E(1 min-24 h) pools (E((available))), accounting for an average of 57.62% of total soil Pb, were significantly correlated with both the L values and with Pb extracted from soil with EDTA.
开发了使用稳定同位素示踪剂((207)Pb)的同位素稀释法来测定污染土壤中铅的有效性。这些方法包括测定E值(同位素可交换库)、L值(植物易变库)和同位素交换动力学(IEK)。在添加示踪剂后,基于对土壤溶液中(207)Pb/(208)Pb比值的测量,在不同的交换时间监测同位素可交换铅。溶液中(207)Pb/(208)Pb比值的下降速率可以用与先前使用放射性同位素示踪剂时相同的IEK方程来描述。从长期IEK参数估算的铅污染土壤中同位素可交换铅的量,在长达15天的时间内与直接测定的E值高度吻合。然而,一些拟合的IEK参数值让人怀疑使用(207)Pb进行IEK方法的有效性,这很可能是由于土壤中一些反应性表面对部分示踪剂的不可逆固定所致。使用短期动力学数据估算同位素可交换铅未成功,大大低估了E值。对照(未受污染)土壤的结果变化很大,这很可能是由于示踪剂被土壤固定以及由于溶液中铅浓度低导致分析精度差所致。对E值随时间变化的分区分析表明,在估算污染土壤中生物可利用铅方面具有很大潜力。从E(1)(min)和E(1 min - 24 h)库(E((可利用)))的总和获得的有效铅量,平均占土壤总铅量的57.62%,与L值以及用EDTA从土壤中提取的铅均显著相关。