Lu Bing, Fu Chuan-Gang, Liu Lian-Jie, Meng Rong-Gui, Yu En-Da, Jin Guo-Xiang, Xing Jun-Jie, Yu De-Hong
Department of Colorectal Surgery, Changhai Hospital, The Second Military Medical University, Shanghai, P. R. China.
Ai Zheng. 2005 Oct;24(10):1257-60.
BACKGROUND & OBJECTIVE: Though anus-retained operation has became the first choice in radical cure operation for rectal cancer, most surgeons whom fear of dissatisfied bowel control after operation recommend permanent bowel stoma in abdomen for elderly low rectal cancer patients rather than anus-retained operation. This study was to evaluate the bowel control of elderly low rectal cancer patients after anus-retained operation.
A total of 80 elderly low rectal cancer patients were divided into > or =75-year old group (39 patients) and 60-74-year old group (41 patients). Clinical data and follow-up data of the 80 patients were analyzed; bowel function and continence of the 2 groups were compared.
The postoperative 18-month survival rate of all patients was 98.8%. The bowel control statuses of 76 patients were evaluable, of which 36 were in > or =75-year old group, 40 were in 60-74-year old group. Three months after operation, the bowel function was significantly poorer in > or =75-year old group than in 60-74-year old group (P<0.05), but the difference dissolved 6 months after operation (P>0.05). The time of recovering normal defecation frequency was slightly longer in > or =75-year old group than in 60-74-year old group (P>0.05). The prevalence of grade I incontinence 6 months after operation was significantly higher in > or =75-year old group than in 60-74-year old group (36.1% vs. 12.5%, P<0.05), but all symptoms of incontinence were relieved after treatment.
Most elderly low rectal cancer patients could maintain bowel control after anus-retained operation. Age alone should not be a contraindication to a restorative resection for low rectal cancer.
尽管保肛手术已成为直肠癌根治手术的首选,但大多数担心术后排便控制不满意的外科医生建议,老年低位直肠癌患者应行腹部永久性肠造口术而非保肛手术。本研究旨在评估老年低位直肠癌患者保肛手术后的排便控制情况。
80例老年低位直肠癌患者分为≥75岁组(39例)和60~74岁组(41例)。分析80例患者的临床资料和随访资料;比较两组的肠功能和控便能力。
所有患者术后18个月生存率为98.8%。76例患者的排便控制情况可评估,其中≥75岁组36例,60~74岁组40例。术后3个月,≥75岁组的肠功能明显比60~74岁组差(P<0.05),但术后6个月差异消失(P>0.05)。≥75岁组恢复正常排便频率的时间比60~74岁组略长(P>0.05)。术后6个月,≥75岁组Ⅰ度失禁的发生率明显高于60~74岁组(36.1%比12.5%,P<0.05),但所有失禁症状经治疗后均缓解。
大多数老年低位直肠癌患者保肛手术后可维持排便控制。年龄不应单独作为低位直肠癌保肛手术的禁忌证。