Verstichel P
Service de Neurologie, Centre Hospitalier Intercommunal, Créteil.
Rev Neurol (Paris). 2005 Sep;161(8-9):804-16. doi: 10.1016/s0035-3787(05)85139-2.
The association of prosopagnosia and false recognition of faces is unusual and contributes to our understanding of the generation of facial familiarity.
A 67-year-old man with a left prefrontal traumatic lesion, developed a temporal variety of fronto-temporal dementia (semantic dementia) with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. Cerebral imagery demonstrated a bilateral, temporal anterior atrophy predominating in the right hemisphere. The main cognitive signs consisted in severe difficulties to recognize faces of familiar people (prosopagnosia), associated with systematic false recognition of unfamiliar people.
Neuropsychological testing indicated that the prosopagnosia probably resulted from the association of an associative/mnemonic mechanism (inability to activate the Face Recognition Units (FRU) from the visual input) and a semantic mechanism (degradation of semantic/biographical information or deconnexion between FRU and this information). At the early stage of the disease, the patient could activate residual semantic information about individuals from their names, but after a 4-year course, he failed to do so. This worsening could be attributed to the extension of the degenerative lesions to the left temporal lobe. Familiar and unfamiliar faces triggered a marked feeling of knowing. False recognition concerned all the unfamiliar faces, and the patient claimed spontaneously that they corresponded to actors, but he could not provide any additional information about their specific identities. The coexistence of prosopagnosia and false recognition suggests the existence of different interconnected systems processing face recognition, one intended to identification of individuals, and the other producing the sense of familiarity. Dysfunctions at different stages of one or the other of these two processes could result in distortions in the feeling of knowing.
From this case and others reported in literature, we propose to complete the classical model of face processing by adding a pathway linked to limbic system and frontal structures. This later pathway could normally emit signals for familiarity, essentially autonomic, in response to the familiar faces. These signals, primitively unconscious, secondly reach consciousness and are then integrated by a central supervisor system which evaluates and verifies identity-specific biographical information in order to make a decision about the sense of familiarity.
面孔失认症与对面孔的错误识别之间的关联并不常见,有助于我们对面部熟悉感产生的理解。
一名67岁男性,左侧前额叶有创伤性病变,患有一种伴有肌萎缩侧索硬化的颞叶型额颞叶痴呆(语义性痴呆)。脑成像显示双侧颞叶前部萎缩,以右侧半球为主。主要认知症状包括难以识别熟人面孔(面孔失认症),并伴有对陌生人的系统性错误识别。
神经心理学测试表明,面孔失认症可能是由联想/记忆机制(无法从视觉输入激活人脸识别单元(FRU))和语义机制(语义/个人信息退化或FRU与该信息之间的脱节)共同作用导致的。在疾病早期,患者可以从名字中激活关于个体的残留语义信息,但经过4年病程后,他无法再做到这一点。这种恶化可归因于退行性病变扩展到左侧颞叶。熟悉和不熟悉的面孔都会引发明显的知晓感。错误识别涉及所有不熟悉的面孔,患者会自发声称这些面孔对应演员,但他无法提供关于他们具体身份的任何额外信息。面孔失认症和错误识别的共存表明存在不同的相互连接系统来处理人脸识别,一个用于识别个体,另一个产生熟悉感。这两个过程中任何一个在不同阶段的功能障碍都可能导致知晓感的扭曲。
从这个病例以及文献中报道的其他病例来看,我们建议通过添加一条与边缘系统和额叶结构相连的通路来完善经典的面孔处理模型。这条后来的通路通常会针对熟悉的面孔发出关于熟悉感的信号,主要是自主的。这些信号最初是无意识的,其次进入意识,然后由一个中央监督系统整合,该系统评估并核实特定身份的个人信息,以便对熟悉感做出判断。