Lopez Laureen M, Grimes David A, Schulz Kenneth F
Family Health International, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina 27709, USA.
Obstet Gynecol Surv. 2005 Nov;60(11):746-52. doi: 10.1097/01.ogx.0000182905.71077.13.
Nonhormonal drugs for contraception in men may have advantages over hormonal methods. The nonhormonal methods can have more rapid onset and less interference with androgen-dependent functions. This systematic review summarizes the clinical studies evaluating nonhormonal drugs administered to men for contraception. Relevant clinical results were found for gossypol, which is derived from the cotton plant, and for extracts of Tripterygium, a plant used in Chinese traditional medicine. Randomized, controlled trials were available on the efficacy of gossypol and on the effect of gossypol on potassium levels. Gossypol had problems with low efficacy and toxicity. For Tripterygium, 2 observational studies described men who were treated for rheumatoid arthritis. Although sperm density was lower among those taking Tripterygium, later reports indicated some toxicity. Nonclinical research continues on isolates of Tripterygium. No clinical studies for contraception in men were found for nonhormonal vaccines or neem, which is also a plant used for medicinal purposes. Clinical trials studied injecting styrene maleic anhydride into the vas deferens, but no comparative data were provided. At this time, no safe and effective nonhormonal drug is available for contraception in men.
Obstetricians & Gynecologists, Family Physicians.
After completion of this article, the reader should be able to state that the number of studies concerning the use of nonhormonal drugs for male contraception are very limited, point out that the two nonhormonal drugs used to a small degree have varying results and serious side effects, and recall that there are limited clinical studies on use of vas deferens injections and vaccines in humans.
男性使用非激素避孕药可能比激素方法具有优势。非激素方法起效可能更快,对雄激素依赖性功能的干扰更小。本系统评价总结了评估男性使用非激素药物避孕的临床研究。已发现从棉花植物中提取的棉酚以及中药雷公藤提取物有相关临床结果。有关于棉酚疗效及棉酚对钾水平影响的随机对照试验。棉酚存在疗效低和毒性问题。对于雷公藤,有2项观察性研究描述了接受类风湿关节炎治疗的男性。虽然服用雷公藤的男性精子密度较低,但后来的报告指出存在一些毒性。对雷公藤的分离物仍在继续进行非临床研究。未发现关于非激素疫苗或印楝(也是一种药用植物)用于男性避孕的临床研究。临床试验研究了向输精管注射苯乙烯马来酸酐,但未提供比较数据。目前,尚无安全有效的非激素药物可用于男性避孕。
妇产科医生、家庭医生。
阅读本文后,读者应能够指出关于男性使用非激素药物避孕的研究数量非常有限,指出少量使用的两种非激素药物有不同结果且有严重副作用,并回忆起关于输精管注射和疫苗在人体使用方面的临床研究有限。